So today's (and tomorrow's) shave is a shave-off comparison between the Vector and the brass Colonial General. (I was the last person on the General pass-around and Josh was nice enough to let me hold on to it for a little while longer. Figured I should take my chance since he's on a different continent at the moment.) When I tried the General last week, I thought it was great. But in my mind, I thought I ought to like the Vector more. Today was a chance to find out head to head.
The shave:
Preshave (not shown): Grooming Dept Lavender Preshave
Soap: Barrister & Mann Barrister's Reserve Lavender
Brush: Paladin Cleo
Razor/Blade (left): Colonial General with Schick Proline P-30 (2)
Razor/Blade (right): Blackland Vector with Schick Proline P-30 (2)
AS: ABC Almond Oil Aftershave Milk
I kept with another of my reliable soaps so that I could concentrate on the razors and their shaves. Today was an early and quick day for me since I had to drive my son's carpool to school. So just 2 passes and done fairly quickly. First up was the General on the left side. Although it was heavy, the General glided down my face and gave me a smooth ride WTG. The Vector was a bit more lively and felt a little rougher on the first WTG pass. (As an aside, I started shaving with the non-blade side of the head. Assume that you get used to it.)
As I re-lathered I wondered whether my expectations were all wrong. Would I like the General more? As I had my second pass (XTG with cleanup), no clear answer appeared. The General felt great. But the Vector seemed to calm down a little and felt smoother. And the final product after the AS dried down was very nice for both. If I had to choose, though, I'd say that the Vector side was a little smoother than the General.
As I write this nearly 7 hours later, I have clear feelings of whiskers on both sides and there's not really a perceptible difference between them.
So - a draw? I was hoping that there would be a clear winner that would guide me one way or the other. I'm going to do one more head-to-head competition tomorrow and really focus on making sure I use no pressure. Hopefully that will give me a clearer picture.