I definitely see how many soap makers would have aftershave sales lagging soap sales, but I see that primarily because there are a lot of scents out there that I’d love to shave with.... but I don’t want to smell like as the day goes on. So far, you’ve come up with scents that people would like using as a scent throughout the day.
Is also offer the converse in sales methodology. When I find a scent set that I love, I generally use about two bottles of a splash per one tub of soap. That’s just the way my personal usage goes. And that may offset some of the prior reasoning. But I know folks who splash with reckless abandon are probably the minority.
As stated before, there are many companies that do soaps only, and no matching splashes. I agree, that I’d love to see some matching splashes from Mystic Water and CBL Soaps.
Because of the lack of Aftershave from some artisans, and the scents I wouldn’t want an aftershave to match anyway, I find myself mixing soap and aftershave scents the majority of the time anyway. So, there is absolutely a market for Aftershaves alone with no accompanying soap, so long as they were general or universal scents with a broad range and not super specific scents.
I change my soaps daily.... rarely sticking with the same soap two days in a row, so I’m less likely to get the benefit of daily usage of your soaps, but I’m more inclined to use your skin food more often to get the benefits from that.