Never tried Floid Blue. When I came into wet shaving, people were lamenting its recent discontinuance. I was new to the game, and was happily trying everything that sounded good, so I never missed it, though you could find it on ebay at the time (at a markup, of course). Captain's Choice Co9T came out shortly after I came aboard. I was a big fan of all the Captain's AS splashes.RazoRock "Blue Barbershop" splash (closest splash scent-wise to original Floid Blue to my nose)