The Shaving Cadre

Welcome to The Shaving Cadre, a forum dedicated to gentlemanly discourse about wet shaving and other topics of common interests. Membership is always free so register today and join in the fun

Down in the Heart of Texas!

Honing #2- Lapping Film

Be sure your lapping plate is very flat and very smooth. Polished marble works good if it is truly flat. A sink cutout from a polished granite countertop will usually work. A piece of very heavy glass, like from a glass coffeetable top, is excellent. Regardless, make sure it is bigger than the biggest piece of film you might use. The ThorLabs sheets are 9 x 13, so a 14" long x 4" wide piece of glass would be ideal. One of the biggest advantages of film is you can have a big honing surface, so don't cripple yourself. I use a 4" x 12" edge tile but I am thinking about upgrading so I can use TL sheets cut lengthways in thirds.

Make sure your film is smooth and flat on the plate, with no bubbles. This is important.

Sheets are usually 8-1/2" x 11" or 9" x 13", and you can cut them into 3 or 4 pieces, each piece should hone a dozen razors, and sheets are less than a buck and a half per sheet, so you do the math. This is a cheap way to hone.

It is also an easy way to hone, easy to learn and to do. Results are extremely consistent, to the point that it really isn't a challenge after about your 4th or 5th razor. Edges are superb. The whole kit is small and light, in spite of having lots of honing real estate. The plate can also be used with wet/dry paper for edge repair or lapping small stones. Breaking the plate is a $5 non-tragedy. There is no romance or nostalgia or zen vibe... just incredible edges.

Here is a typical honing regimen for bevel setting up to shaving.

Set the bevel. 1k wet/dry or 12u film. Make sure that no shoulder or stabilizer intrusion rests on the honing surface. If you need to, hone with the nose trailing the heel, so you get all the edge on the film but not the intrusions. A shoulder intrusion will elevate the heel and prevent its honing. X strokes are not needed. Instead, vary the trail angle of the point, so that no point on the edge keeps passing over a single same point on the film. This evens out irregularities caused by flaws (minor and TBH undetectable and insignificant) in the film or the plate. This supposes that the plate is truly flat and smooth, of course, and no dust or hairs or anything is under the film. For your first few razors, try the burr method. Hone only one side, call it side A. Go 50 strokes or so, then feel the top side, side B, and you should feel a burr running the full length of the edge. If not, keep doing it until you do, counting your strokes. When you get a burr on the full length of the edge, flip the blade and hone side B, to get a burr on side A. Hone side B the same number of strokes as you did side A. Check for burr. If you have a burr full length on side A, then you are done. Otherwise, keep going until you do, then any extra strokes on side B, repeat that number on side A. Now hone with regular alternating laps, i.e. side a, side b, side a, side b, etc for maybe 30 laps. A lap is one round trip back and forth on the film. those 30 alternating laps should remove all trace of burr. Now your bevel is perfectly set.

Always use light pressure, barely more than the weight of the razor. Always keep the spine on the film. At the end, to change directions and go back the other way on the other side, flip the edge out, never the spine. The spine stays on the film, no matter what. It is your bevel guide. Lift the spine from the film, and you messed up. Start all over again.

Got your bevel? Okay, go to your 5u film. Give it 40 or 50 laps and see if you get at least HHT2 on the length of the blade. You could also spoil the edge by drawing it lightly across a glass bottle. Now it should not cut arm hair, at least not very well. Hone until it does, with the full edge, then give the blade a couple dozen more laps, and you are done with the 5u or 6u film.

Go 50 laps or so with the 3u film. This is roughly equivelant to an 8k Norton. You should be able to shave off this film, though it won't be the best shave you have ever gotten. Off the 3u film, you should get a very strong HHT2 or barely HHT3 on the full length of the early dge. With the FOTFT, the Floating Over The Forearm Test, you should be able to float the blade 1/4" over the forearm and it should lop off a few hairs.

Apply the 1u film, which is roughly equivelant to a 12k Naniwa superstone, or 14k ANSI grit. 50 or 60 laps should do it. You should not get a very very strong HHT3. But you are not done. Remove the film and apply a sheet of damp paper to the plate, then lay the film on top of the damp paper. Give it another 40 laps or so. NOW you should have HHT4. The FOTFT should get you several hairs. Now you have a good shaving edge.

But maybe you aren't quite done yet. Try 40 laps on a bench strop pasted with CrOx. Balsa works great, and that's what I use. Now hit the strop about 4 dozen laps and you are ready for a great shave. For maintenance, strop on the balsa and CrOx a dozen laps after each shave, and 4 dozen on your unpasted leather hanging strop before each shave. If the razor ever starts feeling dull, Give t a few dozen laps on the 1u film over damp paper again.

Dry your films well and store them for re-use. Each piece can be used about a dozen times.

You should only have to set your bevel once. But you also should not damage your razor. If you do, you get to do edge repair and bevel setting all over again. So close yoru razor carefully, don't let other people handle your razors, and be careful to not drop your razor or clang it against sink or faucet. Happy Shaves!



 
Lapping film might be the best way to get started honing. It probably gives some of the most consistently good results out of everything else I’ve tried, and even though the prices have gone up considerably in the last couple years it is still the most inexpensive way to get high quality edges on your straights.

I got a marble tile from one of the box stores, had them cut it in thirds and used one for the lapping film. I glued balsa to the other two and pasted them with chromium oxide and iron oxide paste for touch ups. Add the price of lapping film to all of that and you’re probably paying less than you would for just a half decent synthetic bevel setting stone.
 
Honing #3- Pasted Balsa



Having gone into some detail when asked or prompted in many threads, I thought I should comprehensively lay out the method in a separate thread, for reference.

Thing 1. The Balsa Strop.

Buy 3" wide balsa. Best to buy a 36" length. It is cheaper. Hobby Hut, Hobby Lobby, and other brick and mortars carries it. Or purchase online, at 3x the cost. 1/2" thick works well. Cut it into 3 12" pieces. For best results, which I believe are the only results worth pursuing, glue the balsa to a heavy piece of glass, or marble tile cut to size. Not wood. Not plastic. The idea is to bond the balsa to a dimensionally stable substrate, to fight the tendency of the balsa to warp.

The balsa must be lapped, for best results, which as I already pointed out, are the only type of results worth pursuing. Even if it looks flat and smooth. try 220 or 320 grit sandpaper. Or 400. Whatevah. Or a progression. Spray the back side of the sandpaper with Loctite or 3M spray adhesive. Just a faint dusting of the adhesive works great. Carefully stick the sandpaper to a polished granite countertop or a large heavy piece of glass. The flatter, the better. Eyeball flat is not good enough. Make sure the sandpaper goes on smooth and tight with no bubbles or wrinkles. This is extremely important. Now place the balsa face down on the sandpaper and carefully rub rub rub. When you see you have created a whole new surface, obviously the balsa is now as flat as the sandpaper. So, the flatter, the better.

Thing 2. The Diamond Paste.

I have not experimented much yet with finer grits than .1u, so that is the finest I can authoritively comment on. You need .1u, and .25u, and .5u. If you made 3 pieces, that works out well. I get mine from www.tedpella.com but there are a lot of vendors. It is sold in as high as 50% diamond but there is no need to go over 10%. The reason is, less is more. You want the diamond crystals embedded into the balsa, not rolling and scooting around on top of it. You can also get 1u and 3u, both of which are handy for polishing even if you dont use them on balsa much or at all.

Thing 3. Putting it all together.

It only takes a little bit. If you think you got enough, then you probably have about 3x too much. You MUST NOT have a coating on the balsa. You want a very small amount, rubbed in to the balsa. About 1/3 of a pinto bean worth or a bit less. Spread it around and rub it in good. You can thin it down with acetone or something if you like, for better distribution. Now, this is very important. It doesn't matter if you contaminate a coarse grit with a finer one. But you must NEVER let a coarser grit contaminate a finer one. the way it works is each stage makes scratches in the steel, the size of which is determined by the grit size. Each grit must totally eliminate the coarser scratches of the previous grit, replacing it with its own finer scratches. Even a few crystals of a coarser grit basically ruin your results from the finer grit. So, always clean your hands thoroughly when going from grit to grit. Applying diamond to the balsa, start with the finer grit first. Label it by writing the grit size on the ends of the balsa. Do the .1u balsa, then the .25u balsa, then the .5u balsa, etc. Now the proper sign is μ which stands for micron, but we usually use "u" because it is right there on the keyboard.

Thing 4. Using it.

You COULD just use the balsa to touch up an edge that is failing, but I prefer to hit it after every shave, so I never experience a dull or dulling edge. At least, not often. I go 2 or 3 dozen laps on the .25u, then a like number on the .1u. Fairly light pressure. Edge trailing. Use a slight x stroke even though the balsa is wider than the razor's edge. Always wipe the blade VERY WELL after stropping on a pasted balsa or between grits. You MUST NOT contaminate the finer balsa with coarser diamond, or get any diamond on your regular leather hanging strop. You will NOT GET BEST RESULTS if that happens. And best results are the only results worth pursuing. Sometimes I skip the .25u and just go 4 dozen laps on the .1u. I finish by laying the blade on the balsa and drawing it straight across and off the balsa. This helps to remove any fin edge. Occasionally it will seem like my edge is starting to go north on me, and that is when I go with the .5u or 1u. I strop until I am satisfied with the way the razor treetops forearm hair, then I hit my finer grits as usual.

Thing 5. Improving it.

After final stropping on diamond/balsa, I like to give my razor a special treat. I keep a piece of 1/16" thick, 3"wide balsa unpasted. I rest one end on a bench or counter or table, and hold the other end in my left hand. I strop on this very flexible unpasted balsa sheet, letting it sag slightly, about like a hanging strop drawn moderately tight. This seems to remove any vestiges of fin edge much better than linen. I am still experimenting with this technique but it is definitely an improvement.

Thing 5. Maintaining it.

After a few weeks, you may find that the balsa needs a refresh of diamond. You could just add a bit more, about half of what you used when you first pasted the balsa, but for BEST POSSIBLE results, which are the only kind of results worth pursuing, go ahead and re-lap the balsa. Sure, you got it flat, but it isn't flat anymore. Flatter is better.

Thing 6.. Other abrasives.

I have been asked again and again if CrOx (Chromium Oxide) won't work. Yes, it does work. I just don't believe it works as well as diamond. First of all there is basically only one grade of CrOx. Call it .5u, or call it .3u. The particle variation is so wide that it is practically the same whichever way you call it. If you use CrOx and you want to go finer, get some FeOx, or Iron Oxide, which runs around .1u grit size. Yes, they are cheaper than diamond. But you use so little, the cost is irrelevant. I strongly recommend going with diamond. Best possible results, right? You might also take a look at CBN, Cubic Nitride Boron or something like that. The new thing.

IN CLOSING, I just want to say that this works. I basically never have to re-hone a razor that I have maintained with this method. YMMV, I am sure, but there is no reason not to try it my way. Hardly any steel is lost even in daily use. 1u is approximately equivelant to a 12k Naniwa Superstone. .1u of course is 10x finer. Some naysayers will state that this will surely cause a harsh edge. I use this method and the only kind of edges I get are sh-sh-sh-sh-SHARRRRRRRPPPPPPPP ones. Give it a go, and if you do it right you will love it.
 
Honing #4- My Honing Notes

Equipment:
Lapping film (not paper) at least these grits - 9u, 5u, 3u & 1u

Marble tile, granite or heavy glass. I use a 4x12” marble tile from HD. (2 pack $7)

Squeegee. I use an old, plastic gift card.

Spray bottle of water.

Clean hand towel.

All of my work is edge leading for honing. I only use spine leading strokes for stropping on balsa or leather.

My progression:
600 grit WD sandpaper (if needed for chip removal on edge). Can also use 30u lapping film.

1000 grit WD sandpaper (bevel set)
Bevel set using the burr method. Can also use 12u lapping film.

Lapping film- 9u, 5u, 3u & 1u (40-60 laps on each film)

Use a loupe or pocket microscope to watch your edge through the entire progression. Edge should run full length of blade. Each film removes scratches of previous film. When finished on 1u, the edge should be mirror smooth. Finish on pasted balsa.

Pasted balsa- .3u and then .1u (Chromium/Iron Oxide) 40-60 laps each balsa. Wipe blade when changing media. Do not cross contaminate the compounds.

Maintenance:
50 laps .1u balsa after shaving. 12 laps on leather. Then 50 on leather before shaving again.

Coming Soon-
Pasted balsa- .5u, .25u, .1u (diamond paste)
50 laps on each

Diamond paste is sold in as high as 50% diamond but there is no need to go over 10%. The reason is, less is more”
 
That’s a ton of info. If you skip the oxides and go to diamond paste for your balsa strops, you will get a hyper sharp, yet smooth edge.

I don’t have the diamond paste, but used a razor sharpened on it. It was the sharpest and smoothest that I ever shaved with.
 
Journal Entry 23

Pre-shave: Hot Shower & Jack Black's Face Buff
Razor: Rockwell 6C
Blade: Gillette Silver Blue
Brush: Yaqi Rainbow Synthetic
Bowl: PAA Scuttle
Soap: Barrister and Man Seville
Aftershave: Osma Alum & Stirling Tea Tree, Witch Hazel, Aloe & Lucky Tiger Splash
Moisturizer: CeraVe Moisturizing Cream

Results:

I figured I would participate in the April shave soap themes, which will be an excuse to buy some soaps so that I can participate everyday! (We'll see...)
Anyway, I went with Barrister and Man Seville for "B" day which is also their barbershop scent. Their description calls it "God's barbershop". Personally I get more of a citrus forward scent. The scent however is pleasant and I would consider this a spring or summertime soap. The performance is really, really good. I would put this up there with Ethos and CBL as far as slickness and cushion, and I think it may be in a class of it's own as far as residual slickness. This was just the sample so I will definitely be buying a full tub of this in a couple months.
The blade is one that I recently got from my blade sample pack. I really like the GSB's and right now they are rivaling Personna Lab Blues for my favorite blade.

Thanks for reading Cadre, and I hope y'all are having a good week!
 
Journal Entry 24

Pre-shave: Hot Shower & Jack Black's Face Buff
Razor: Rockwell 6C
Blade: Gillette Silver Blue (2)
Brush: AP Shave Co. SynBad Ruby
Bowl: PAA Scuttle
Soap: California Sunrise
Aftershave: Osma Alum & Stirling Tea Tree, Witch Hazel, Aloe & Skin Bracer
Moisturizer: CeraVe Moisturizing Cream

Results:

For "C" day I went with CBL's California Sunrise. I really enjoy using this soap. The scent is relaxing and the lather is slick with a nice cushion. I went with the #2 plate on the razor since I shave yesterday and that worked out really nice. I have no irritation and I came away with a DFS+! I can't wait to try the CBL soaps that come with the 2nd anniversary box.

Thanks for reading Cadre and I hope y'all have a nice weekend!
 
I’m with you! Can’t wait to try all the stuff!

Oh yeah I am definitely excited to try the LNHC soap because of everything I have heard about her products, and of course Stirling Hipster. The brush looks awesome. Definitely a lot of good stuff. I was just talking about the CBL because I used one of his products today.
 
Journal Entry 24

Pre-shave: Hot Shower & Jack Black's Face Buff
Razor: Rockwell 6C
Blade: Gillette Silver Blue (4)
Brush: WCS Honeycomb Badger
Bowl: PAA Scuttle
Soap: Ethos Grooming Essentials: Succèss
Aftershave: Osma Alum & Stirling Tea Tree, Witch Hazel, Aloe & Ethos Grooming Essentails Skin Food Splash: Succèss
Moisturizer: CeraVe Moisturizing Cream

Results:

I forgot to post my journal yesterday, but for "D" day I used Dragonsbeard and for "E" day I used the new Succès (Pineapple Noir). The decent of this stuff is fantastic. To me it is in the same wheelhouse as M&M Trinity, Stirling Executive Man, and Stirling Baker Street, but the pineapple gives it a very unique scent. My wife kept taking the soap from me to smell it throughout the day.
As far as performance goes it is another top notch product. Having used the Dragonsbeard soap the previous day I can tell a difference between Frank's soap base and the collaboration. Succès seemed to have better cushion, similar slickness, and noticeably better residual slickness. Awesome job Frank! Super excited to have this soap base in the Dragonsbeard scent.
The skin food was just as good as the soap. The pineapple scent seemed more potent in the splash, so the combination of the soap and splash gave it a very fresh smell. Not too sweet, but a very fresh cologne scent. My skin feels great after applying two splashes and I could not be happier with my purchase.
Frank also sent a sample of the Lavender Skin Food Splash and wow that stuff smells incredible. It doesn't have a powdery smell like most florals, but smells like a very fresh and clean lavender. Not so much a cologne, but definitely relaxing. I told my wife that I would have to get it and after she smelled it she agreed. So I will definitely be getting the Lavender soap and skin food soon, and keep my eye out on his next releases.
The Gillette Silver Blue is still going strong and so far it is my favorite blade. Still have a few others to try out, but I want to see how long I can use this blade.

Homefront:

The baby's room is done! Super happy that we have that done and all we have left to do is finish texturing and painting the guest room and then anticipate the actual birth.

Thanks for reading Cadre! Sorry for rambling a little bit, and I hope y'all had a great weekend!
 
My wife was the same way.

Then she snagged a synth brush and some soaps from a big PIF that I won. There was no going back. She now has two brushes, her own soaps and will rifle through my soaps when the mood strikes her. She’s a big Stirling fan too.
 
My wife was the same way.

Then she snagged a synth brush and some soaps from a big PIF that I won. There was no going back. She now has two brushes, her own soaps and will rifle through my soaps when the mood strikes her. She’s a big Stirling fan too.

So far she really likes Stirling Baker Street, Ethos Succès, and the Lavender Ethos. She likes my other soaps, but I don't see her using the darker scents like Dragonsbeard, CBL ROS, or Ghost Town Barber.
 
Nice job getting the room finished!

Pineapple is such a great notes in soaps, aftershaves, and frags. I’m really looking forward to trying that soap.
 
Back
Top