I both agree and disagree when teaching CC we tell our students that the stress of the situation make handguns useless unless you are trained to breath Handguns in the house are good but be prepared to pull the trigger many times as you WILL miss alot, and even more in the dark if you do not have laser sights where as a short shotgun give a good pattern spread and also the racking of a twelve guage is usually followed by a breaking of glass, and running feet. Having been involved, aside from military, in a live shoot in a robbery and assault attempt. The dynamic changes dramatically,
I don't dispute anything you said. Especially the part about racking a round in. That is a very distinctive sound.
I believe the bottom line is that it is going to fall back to your mindset and training.
First and most importantly, if you don't have the proper mindset to pull the trigger, leave whatever firearm you have locked up and grab a phone on your way out of the window.
As far as the different firearms...
Pros for handguns: They are easier to retain/harder to get ahold of. They allow better mobility in confined areas. They are easier to get into position and employ if you are taken down.
Cons: They have a smaller hit area and need enough training/familiarity that they can be point shot with a good degree of accuracy. Not good at creating distance if taken by surprise. Need to maintain a certain grip to point shoot accurately and to let the firearm cycle properly.
Pros for shotguns: That slide sound of a pump. Can be used to create distance if taken by surprise. Greater stopping power.
Cons: Harder to maneuver in tight quarters. If taken down, it can't be employed as a firearm. Can be grabbed easier and provides more leverage against retention. Requires more accuracy than most people think at room distances.
Even with a defensive 12 guage with cylinder bore and 00 buck, a typical spread in 12 feet (average room size) is less than 5 inches.
My personal experience leans more towards combat pistol shooting and close range HTH. In most defensive pistol matches, I never look at my sights. After 80,000+ rounds in all kinds of positions, I have the muscle memory to know where the muzzle is pointing and where the projectile is going.
That said, not everyone is the same. So just because it works for me, doesn't mean it will be best for everyone. I can only reliably give you what I know and let you make your own decisions from there.
So here is my main motto. TRAIN.... No matter what you are most comfortable with and decide upon.
Handguns, learn to point shoot. Make yourself familiar enough that you know it is pointing where you are. Learn when and how to retain it. Shotguns, again, learn to point shoot them and how to retain them. Then train some more so you don't loose that muscle memory because if the
![Poop :poop: :poop:]()
hits the fan, your brain isn't going to handle things for you.
And be open minded about your training. You will never know it all so don't be opposed to listening to people that have different experiences.
![Thumbs up (y) (y)]()