Not sure how I got so far behind in your journal Dave, but I did, and I apologize. I am also very sorry that you are struggling so with the traditional straight razor. With 68 shaves in with a straight (I assume that includes AC straights as well) it is a little perplexing as to what might be the issue. Certainly blade keenness comes to mind as a potential problem. Shave ready is a subjective term by one person intended to be applicable to the entire population of shavers. Sometimes this is the case, but often it is not. Shave ready really needs to be discerned by the individual shaver. Not sure where all of your razors have come from (with respect to honing) but perhaps you have not had one that suits your face. I know Chris H. has this issue with his whiskers. An edge that gave me a BBS only will get him to DFS.
Good luck with your continued journey though. Perhaps visit the traditional straight when you have plenty of time, and no expectations. Slow it down. Today I was shaving and I had a bunch of lather accumulated on the blade. As I mentioned in my journal, all of the shave videos popping up here had me go through my routine, thinking about what I would be saying if I were doing a shave video. Well, on my initial WTG pass, I typically will shave the entire left side of my face to the midline, below the lip, without rinsing the lather off. I always will rinse for the below the nose pass so as to see better the edge, and I perform the under nose scoop which would deposit the built up later above my lip. When I started the pass from the corner of my mouth down to my chin, I made a mental note that the amount of lather on the blade would not allow the viewer (nor me) a clear view of what I was actually doing, yet I do it like this every day. Then the idea was reinforced in my consciousness that I shave more by feel than I do by sight. I know that I had talked about this many times in my journal at the other site when I was learning, but when the feel of the bevel on the skin is learned, the shaves do improve. The feel is a combination of angle and pressure, and it can only be achieved through trial and error. For the razors that I have honed and are currently using, I will say that I do use more pressure than if I were shaving with an AC type razor with a fresh Pro Super. And I learned that by trial and error as well.