Last week I asked the concierge group for some suggestions as I wanted to explore Japanese whisky and scotch. I have never tried any Japanese whisky and it has been at least 18 years since I have had any form of Scotch excluding the Del Bac Whisky I was gifted in last year's gift exchange (thanks
@uacowboy). The Del Bac is technically a single malt AMERICAN whiskey but it borrows heavily from the scotish methods/techniques so the product is similar in many ways to scotch whisky. I didn't get much in the way of recomendations for a Japanese whisky but they graciously provided a couple recommendations for scotch whisky. ...ok "they" was mostly the Dave's (what lushes they are).
@BarberDave recommended a bottle of Dalmore Cigar Malt and
@NurseDave suggested a Craigellachie 13yr single malt. At $150+ the Dalmore was intriguing but probably a better second bottle than first. The Craigellachie is more approachable in the $50 range. Sadly, my local liquor guy had very little to choose from in both categories. He did have an assortment of Dalmore but not the cigar malt, I may end up trying the Dalmore 21yr down the road. He did have a couple bottles of higher end Japanese whiskys but I knew very little about them so I didn't grab anything from the top shelf. In fact, his "top shef" scotch went from Dalmor down to Glenlivet, so I didn't grab anything there either.
As I parused the shelves I found a bottle of Suntory Toki Japanese Whisky (a well regarded entry level example of a Japanese whisky) but I didn't find any other scotches. But I DID find a few bottles of Jameson Irish Whisky that sounded interesting and were attractivly priced. I think there was an Orange, a stout and the one I got which was IPA barrel aged. So what did I think of these purchases?
Suntory Loki-
I chose to drink this neat at room temp for my initial impression then again neat with a cigar. It is smother than many of the American Whiskey's I have had but it still had a bit of a bite. The flavor was enjoyable but not very complex or unique. Giving a goos "Swooshing around" in my mouth did expose more character than simply sipping it. When paired with a cigar it comes accross much smoother but the mellow flavor does nothing to add or detract to the cigar experience. My over all impression is that at around $40 this is a decent whisky to have on the shelf but not one I find myself craving more of or thinking about after.
Jameson IPA-
Again, this was taken neat for initial impressions but I have not paired it with a cigar for evaluation on that front. To be clear, I have no experience with Irish Whisky so I have no idea how this is supposed to taste or how it compares to a traditional aged Irish Whisky. My initial impresion was that it was very smooth (much smoother than the Japenese whisky I had tried previously) and almost boardered on watery. Fortunatly upon further exploration I found it had more taste than what I initially thought, giving it a good swooshing around in the mouth really exposed the sweet floral and fruity notes that I associate with an IPA without all the hopiness . Overall I find this whisky much more unique than the Japanese Whisky and one that I can see myself enjoying another glass or two of. On the whole, I think the IPA characteristics imparted in this whisky work well BUT also make it clearly floral/fruity which I think I would tire of rather quickly if this were the only bottle on the shelf.
I still need to find (and buy) a decent Scotch to try, even if it is only a 50ml bottle. I supposed I owe it to the Irish Whisky's to try a more "Traditional" aged version before deciding on how I feel about them on the whole. While I can say with certainty I do NOT like Canadian Whisky, Irish and Japanese whisky's may still have a spot on my shelf.