Dear Mr. Modern Williams,
I have to say that this last puck ended up being a much different experience than I have had over the past number of years. Way back when, before I knew shaving was more than just shaving and forums, websites and loads of products existing, I used you and the Wilkinson Sword bowls with the cheapie drugstore Wilkie brush. Sloppy goop that worked well enough with my old Sensor and Weishi (and superspeed from my teens) but shaving was a morning chore.
Even when I became shaving-world enlightened, I struggled using you, Mr. Modern Williams, whether it be with badger, boar or horse and whether I pre-soaked/saturated you or grated you. You provided poor lather that was slick, but dissipated.
Now I've figure you out. No special pre-treatment, just load you heavily as is and away you go. I really think the issue was one of lading. I loaded to visually have the same amount of proto-lather as other products and then started face/bowl-lathering. Needless to say, you are more than affordable, so it is not like I am using $1/shave worth of product.
Thanks to the last 2 months, I have learned that you are not a sucky soap at all, but a pretty serviceable one at that and quite affordable.
Maybe we'll cross paths again somewhere down the road, but I promise, next time I won't cross the street or pretend to admire someone's garden so I don't have to look at you when we pass each other.
Be seeing ya!
Woodpusher