Just as an FYI, the company itself doesn't have that type of return policy. I was referring to the baby registry return policy - for example, we had the Brezza on our BuyBuyBaby registry, and if someone (even yourself) purchased the item off the registry, you had a full year to return the item as opposed to the standard 60 days. Think all our registries (BBB, Target, Amazon) offered the 1 year return window. Basically if there were items we wanted but didn't necessarily register for, we still added it to the registry after-the-fact and purchased it for ourselves to have that nice long return window.
Indeed the rental option is nice. Wife's cousin did that on their third kid and her testimony is what got it on the radar for us. We were planning on waiting for the 30% off sale as we're on the first kid and plan to have a couple more, so spreading the money out across 2 or 3 kids made purchasing easier to stomach. Receiving it as a gift from the inlaws was a very welcomed surprise, especially to our checking account!
We were told by many friends and family to make sure to evaluate all diaper options before committing to a massive box of any brand. We've come to love the Target Up&Up diapers. They are (of course) noticeably cheaper in quality vs Huggies, Pampers, or Kirkland, but are 10 cents a diaper with the Red Card 15% subscription discount, which is 60% cheaper than Huggies and Pampers (which average between 21 and 24 cents each) and 38% cheaper than Kirkland (which are 16 cents each.) We've only had one blow out so far and it was so bad that there is no way any brand would have been able to hang on. We've been limited to newborn and size 1 so far (Kirkland doesn't even make newborn size which is odd) but haven't had any issues with Up&Up and the savings is MASSIVE! Same goes for their diaper wipes - signficiantly cheaper per wipe then even Kirkland, even before the 15% Red Card subscription discount, and have found the dispenser in the Up&Up packs to be much better than Kirkland in terms of one-handed grabbing while changing.