The Shaving Cadre

Welcome to The Shaving Cadre, a forum dedicated to gentlemanly discourse about wet shaving and other topics of common interests. Membership is always free so register today and join in the fun

The Frankenshave Lab

GearNoir

“The Disney Princess’s Apprentice”


Welcome to the Frankenshave Lab!

When it comes to the ultimate finish to our [insert preferred term abbreviation here]BBS shave, we brook no slouches, suffer no fools, spare no expense!

A good aftershave puts a proper cap to our post shave regimen like nothing else!

Sometimes we just can’t find that right match though. The sensory image we want to project for the day just can’t be found on a store shelf (internet or otherwise). That’s the time we must look to the creativity of ourselves, our traditional shaving brethren, and most especially our aftershave enthusiasts who are our mad scientist aftershave mixers in disguise.

This thread is dedicated to the homemade aftershave concoctions of the traditional shaving community. If you have a favored, tried and true aftershave mix, and want to share the wealth, by all means, submit it to the list! This post will be updated with submitted aftershaves periodically.

Currently preferred submissions will look like this:

Name: Name of AS mix. To the best of your ability, if a mix is not your own creation or is an established mix, please try to find and use the original name!

Primary Scent Category: This is currently how the mixes will be ordered, to simplify searches. Scents can be quite subjective, but hopefully this identification will give the main thrust of the overall scent. The Primary Scent Category will be one of the 4 basic divisions of Michael Edwards’ Fragrance Wheel (Floral, Oriental, Woody, Fresh).

Scent Notes: This is where you can let loose your inner AS scent nerd and give a more detailed description of what the heck we’re getting into beyond the most basic Primary Scent Category. As the list grows, mixes may eventually find themselves also sub categorized under Secondary Scent Profiles (see the scent ring of Michael Edwards’ Fragrance Wheel), so you may want to plan ahead and attempt to identify this in this section.

Mix Notes: This is where you detail the combination of ingredients used in the creation of your mix. Please include any specific processes and percentages that are necessary or helpful in creating the mix!

Let the mixing begin!



Michael Edwards Fragrance Wheel Reference:



Frankenshave Lab Submissions (last updated 10/11/18):

Floral Mixes:

Tabacaveg:

Tabac

Pinaud Lilac Vegital

All equal parts.

Oriental Mixes:

Bootlegger’s Bay Rum:

This is the original folks, accept no substitute. Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum, while long lasting, has a very strong burn, and is very clovey and spicy. The Master has real bay oil and a nice scent (although too sweet for some), but has so much glycerin that it can feel tacky or sticky, by itself. Superior 70 is wonderfully cheap, has real Puerto Rican bay oil, and a very high alcohol content (70%), making it more a medicinal rub than an aftershave. But all 3 bay rums mix together for a synergistic bay rum utopia! The alcohol in the Superior 70 cuts down the glycerin in Master, making the glycerin level just right, while it's Puerto Rican bay oil gives it an authentic bay rum scent. The Master’s glycerin nourishes the face and calms down the high alcohol levels in Superior 70 and spice of Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum, making the amount of burn just right. And lastly, the Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum gives the mix its perfect color and longevity of scent, unlike the fleeting scents of some of the higher dollar bay rums. It is the perfect bay rum for the holidays!

Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum

Master Bay Rum

Superior 70 Bay Rum

All equal parts. The longer it ages, the better!

Bootlegger’s El Dorado:

Pinaud Special Reserve is loved by many, just the way it is. However, there are some who just can't warm up to it, even though the idea of a smoky, leather type aftershave appeals to them. For some folks the cheaply made scent of Pinaud Special Reserve is just missing something. The dry down seems old and dusty. Some people call it an 'Old Lady' scent.

Bootlegger’s El Dorado maintains the leathery and smoky notes and what makes Special Reserve... 'Special'. While softening its edges and rounding out the dry down into something a bit more refined, with an added touch of class and a hint of sophistication. If you wanted to like Pinaud Special Reserve, but just couldn’t, then Bootlegger’s El Dorado could be the aftershave for you.

Pinaud Special Reserve

Pinaud Classic Vanilla

English Leather

Two parts each Special Reserve and Vanilla. One part Leather.

Bootlegger’s Lime Bay Rum:

All the benefits of the original Bootlegger’s Bay Rum with the added scent of Lime! Lots of different lime scents were sampled and tested before settling on Pinaud Citrus Musk for this recipe. It blends perfectly with Bootlegger’s Bay Rum, like it was made for Bootlegger’s. The perfect summertime bay rum!

Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum

Master Bay Rum

Superior 70 Bay Rum

Pinaud Citrus Musk

All equal parts.

Bootlegger’s Perfecto Maduro:

Originally, there was only going to be one Bootlegger’s Perfecto recipe. Two recipes were created and samples were sent out to some B&B members for review. The masses spoke and the reviews were split down the middle, so now there are two! Bootlegger’s Perfecto Maduro gets a slight leathery and smoky scent from the addition of Pinaud Special Reserve, making it a darker and richer bay rum, well suited for colder months.

Master Bay Rum

Superior 70 Bay Rum

Vito’s Colonia Tobacco

Pinaud Special Reserve

Equal parts Master, Superior, and Vito’s. Half part Pinaud.

Bootlegger’s Perfecto Virginia:

Many bay rum lovers want a summertime bay rum, without the heavy, cloying scent of clove & spice. Bootlegger’s Perfecto is a light & breezy bay rum, with a light masculine scent of Virginian leaf tobacco, (hence the name "Perfecto") blended with a bright summer scent of orange citrus. Smells like Cuba!

Master Bay Rum

Superior 70 Bay Rum

Vito’s Colonia Tobacco

All equal parts.

Chilly Old Man:

Pinaud Clubman - 12 Pts

Lucky Tiger - 4 Pts

Old Spice - 1 Pt

Dissolve menthol crystals to liking.

Happy Hour:

Pinaud Whiskey Woods

Pinaud Brandy Spice

Pinaud Gentleman’s Gin

All equal parts.

Lucky Old Man:

Pinaud Clubman - 12 Pts

Lucky Tiger - 4 Pts

Old Spice - 1 Pt

Fireman:
Good face feel, smells like you took a Clubman out of the club and put him around a campfire!
4 parts Clubman
1 part Stirling Texas on Fire WH

Orange Spice:

Old Spice - 2 Pts

Florida Water - 1 Pt

Rich’s Dog From Every Town:

Bay Rum mixed from all available sources.

VEZmerize Oriental Spice:
Skin Bracer
Brut
Master Jade
All equal parts.

Woody Mixes:

Fresh Mixes:


Black Box Brut Fresh:

Brut Splash on frag

Generic witch hazel (moderately cut in)

Wintergreen Isopropyl (cut in to taste)

Blue Steele:

Aqua Velva

Florida Water

Bootlegger’s Arctic Lime Blast:

If you are looking for a great lime scented aftershave with the added cooling of the arctic, then this is the blend for you. Pinaud Lime Sec is a sweet lime scent, very sweet (candy-like). Too sweet on its own, for many. Osage Rub tames the sweetness of Pinaud Lime Sec, and in return the great lime scent eliminates the medicinal scent of Osage Rub. Another great cooling summertime scent!

Osage Rub

Pinaud Lime Sec

All equal parts.

Bootlegger's Green Freeze:

Osage Rub is great. It’s a cold blast that feels great on your face, especially in the summer. But unfortunately it smells very medicinal (like Vicks VapoRub) from the menthol and eucalyptus, and it has no lasting scent after the dry down. Skin Bracer has a great scent with notes of vanilla, musk, powder, and lavender (but mostly vanilla). It contains menthol, but doesn’t offer the same punch as Osage Rub. Mixing the two makes the perfect combo! The vanilla from the Skin Bracer is a perfect summer time scent and perfectly masks the medicinal scent of Osage Rub. They both have menthol, but the extra menthol and eucalyptus from Osage Rub, gives the mix an extra cooling boost, taking Skin Bracer to the next, next level! This is a favorite of many AS mixing enthusiasts.

Osage Rub

Mennen Skin Bracer

All equal parts.

Rich’s Mongoose:

Mostly Everclear

Some Glycerine

Then start putting in Menthol crystals till no more will dissolve. Leave a little headroom for more Everclear because sometimes Menthol will precipitate if you exceed a saturated solution.

VEZmerize Blue Floyd:

4711 - 60%

Aqua Velva - 40%



 
I'm no help here but would you be interested in a glass Aqua Velva Bottle ? I have a spare since I decanted to a hand bottle.
 
Look up the recipes for Bootleggers in the Wiki, over there. They are all winners.
 
You’re going to need to get some Skin Bracer. That’s mandatory!
 
You’re going to need to get some Skin Bracer. That’s mandatory!

I’ll be on the lookout!
I'm no help here but would you be interested in a glass Aqua Velva Bottle ? I have a spare since I decanted to a hand bottle.

Thanks Dave, but for the postage I could probably go find a cheapo bottle of hot sauce to dump.

Wait! I just saved us money in this, our money saving hobby!
 
Those are all great Aftershaves for mixing! I am looking forward to see your concoctions!
 
Perhaps Chris will come up with a new concoction that we all must have!
 
Here are some:

Oriental Spice (VEZmerize)
Skin Bracer
Brut
Master Jade
Blue Floyd (VEZmerize)
4711 - 60%
Aqua Velva - 40%

Tabacaveg
Self Explanatory

Bootlegger's Green Freeze (my favorite Bootleggers)
Osage Rub
Skin Bracer

Blue Steele
Aqua Velva
Florida Water

Orange Spice
Old Spice - 2 Pts
Florida Water - 1 Pt
 
Blue Steel!



My current “go-to” clean scent - a refreshing, lightly scented Brut AS:
Brut Splash on frag
Generic witch hazel (moderately cut in)
Wintergreen Isopropyl (cut in to taste)
 
I request this week that KJ use Florida Water with a description please.
 
Well, I'm probably ok on not trying that one then.
 
Here are some:

Oriental Spice (VEZmerize)
Skin Bracer
Brut
Master Jade
Blue Floyd (VEZmerize)
4711 - 60%
Aqua Velva - 40%

Tabacaveg
Self Explanatory

Bootlegger's Green Freeze (my favorite Bootleggers)
Osage Rub
Skin Bracer

Blue Steele
Aqua Velva
Florida Water

Orange Spice
Old Spice - 2 Pts
Florida Water - 1 Pt
Little skimpy on your percentages revealed
 
Back
Top