How long did you load the soap? I take back my previous statement, I tried a Nomad puck a long time ago, from 2014ish. I remember having a really tough time with it and shelved it, I have it in a box somewhere. The 1980s-early 2000's soaps are wonderful, but other folks have luck with these later variations too. I did read in a thread some time ago that you should expect to load 2-3 times the amount that you usually do. I have an unused West Indian Lime soap, with a similar label to yours, I may do a test lather on it to see what I can get out of it to compare our experiences.