Sorry Gents, Just saw thisI’m still a noob, so I don’t know much.
The linen on this pass around strop is really soft and flexible. My cotton strop is not as soft and not nearly as flexible. So I started twisting the cotton this way and that. Just working it with my hands and it has started to soften up nicely. I would assume you could do the same with nylon.
I know some guys use old cotton fire hose or seatbelts also. You can use them with or without paste, just depending on what you are wanting to do. I think we should ping @BarberDave because I really don’t know squat
This really comes down to preference. You can get great stropping of an old pair of jeans and is what I recommend for in the beginning or for travel, you can even use Newspaper for that matter. The whole concept is to preserve and burnish and re-align the edge for smoothness. Those that use cotton or Firehose with pastes are actual doing an ad-hoc honing to keep and edge keen. I personally have tried and do not prefer. My feeling is that...
1. if there is a good bevel and keen edge, stropping takes out the harshness
2. unless doing an edge refresh pasted stuff is not necessary
3. K.I.S.S. Keep it simple stupid ( just rubbing metal against a rockk. err in the case rubbing metal against fabric then a cow or horse, LOL)
As to a fabric strop vs a leather. At the microscopic and molecular level although hard is still flexible and most of the time in a cross-hatch pattern. The cotton or linen, by virtue of friction heats the metal ever so slightly and re-aligns not only the molecules but the edge as well, as it over time will bend, chip, crack, but again at the microscopic level that you will never see or feel. and after honing very often you have a foiled edge and the stropping also removes that. the final Strop on the leather burnishes and smooths, my normal routine is this
Pre-and during Shave:
30 Linen / 60 Leather Prior to shave
10 on leather between each pass
25 on linen post shave to dry and align.
Post Bevel Set and Honing:
150-200 on linen
200 on Leather.
I know this was a bit "long winded" but hope it helps. Thanks for taggin me guys
There are also two trains of though Fabric / Leather / Fabric in honing, I do not again K.I.S.S. I English Linen to all other fabric portions as I feel it aligns and smooths the best and give me the feel I like when smoothed and burnished on leather after. I also strop between passes ( old barber trick I learned from Angel Delagadillo ( the Angel of Route 66 ) a barber since the 40's.). I think that keeps the edge consistent But really they do the same thing so finding the ones you feel give you the best results for re--alignment, smoothing and feel are the best.
the old adage is true. "The one YOU like and feel comfortable with is the BEST"