I've still got some Stirling Peach left - I should use some soon.
You should. It's awesome. One of my favorite soaps.
178/216 this morning.
Well, today I tried something new. Something I had never tried before. Something that gets a lot of positive press on the fora. Declaration Grooming! I had never tried any of their soaps before.
CBL was kind enough to include a small sample of the DG Icarus Shore soap when he returned my straight razors to me after honing. As soon as I got the package, I opened the samples and took a big sniff of each. This soap hit me square in the face with a nasty, wet-dog odor and then a bit of an aquatic atop that. I didn't like it at all.
Over the past couple of weeks, I've tried sniffing it a few more times. Each time I got that animalic musk that I really dislike. I figured I'd probably never try this stuff.
But then I read on another forum that if you leave the soap uncovered for a few hours, the animalic smell dissipates and it's not bad (it also said that it the funk returns if you put the lid back on it for awhile). So, last night I decided to uncap the sample in hopes that the scent would be better this morning, and it was!
So I put some of it into my lather bowl and put a tiny bit of water on it while I showered. When it came time to shave, I lathered it up, fearing the wet-dog smell, but for the most part I just got the aquatic scent. It was a fairly generic aquatic scent, so I wasn't that excited about it, but it wasn't bad, and the funk seemed pretty much gone.
So, what about the lather? Well, it took a LONG TIME to get it where I liked it. I was about ready to shave and I remember thinking that I would post that Stirling was better than this stuff, but then I added one more dollop of water and worked it a bit longer and it got really nice, sour-cream like and shiny. It shaved great.
I used the Noonan, which I remembered to strop last night. Three passes to CCS. I used the SBS for touch-ups.
The lather required a bit of work between each pass. It required a TON of water to reach its best self. Post-shave face feel was really good.
Overall, I'd say this lather was really good; 90th percentile at least, but it required a bunch of water and a bunch of work.
About 15 minutes after I capped the sample, I opened it up to give it another sniff, hoping for the pleasant aquatic scent I had during the shave. Nope. Smelled like rancid garbage again. Sigh. Great lather but this soap is probably not for me.
Interestingly, some people say they smell a funk in the background of Mike's and even of Stirling. I don't get that at all from either soap. But the Icarus has it is spades (for ME). I know that noses are different. Great lather, though.
Have a good day!