I have never tried any vintage either, mainly because I don't know what to look for. Anyone want to give us the rundown on the different scents that are readily available? Also, I know Avon does sell some A/S currently, is this still the same stuff, or did it change?
In my experience, the new Avon stuff isn't quite the same. The vintage stuff...all of them...have really good longevity and are not just alcohol, water, and scent. It feels like, well at least to me, that there are some healing ingredients in them also. There are a tone of scents out there...KJ @Spider can probably tell you more about it than I can. As he seems to be a Vintage Avon After Shave museum unto himself!
I'll talk about a couple....starting with probably the most found scent out there...Wild Country. I personally am not big on this scent. I just don't like it. I believe it is supposed to be a Pinaud Clubman Original type scent. Which makes sense, because I am not a Clubman guy either.
Island Lime is well...a lime after shave. But as I said before, I really think it is the only lime after shave out there that lasts more than an hour. Really good longevity.
Windjammer - With a name like Windjammer, I think Avon was going for something nautical. But it's not Old Spice, It's not Cool Water, it's not aquatic at all. To me, it smells like a spicy (think pepper) citrus after shave. This is one of my favorites.
Everest - By far my favorite Avon scent. It's a nice clean cool scent that seems to have something coniferous in it...maybe juniper. Think of an Avon version of Captains Choice North...just a little less forest-y. When I run out of mine and if I can't find anymore...I will seriously be sad.
Bravo - I only have a tiny bit of this left. But I enjoy this as well. It's a bit hard to describe. Think dark orange and oriental spice with a little musk.
I am sure others will come in and give us their impressions of some other Avon Scents!