The Shaving Cadre

Welcome to The Shaving Cadre, a forum dedicated to gentlemanly discourse about wet shaving and other topics of common interests. Membership is always free so register today and join in the fun

Josh's Olfactory Office

Thanks for the reviews.

You must have quite a collection of frags. How do you store them so that they don't degrade over time?

Do you hang on to the stanks you don't like, thinking that your tastes might evolve, or do you move them on?

My Bride lets me know if she likes what I'm wearing or not. Do you consider feedback from certain other people in your reviews/selections?

Thanks again for the reviews. They are fun to read.
 
Thanks for the reviews.

You must have quite a collection of frags. How do you store them so that they don't degrade over time?

Do you hang on to the stanks you don't like, thinking that your tastes might evolve, or do you move them on?

My Bride lets me know if she likes what I'm wearing or not. Do you consider feedback from certain other people in your reviews/selections?

Thanks again for the reviews. They are fun to read.
Great question, and I'm glad you asked!

I do have a rotating medium-large collection. Some guys here have a library!

To keep them alive as long as possible, first, it depends on how old. With vintage, it's best to find the most latest batch and hope they're unused, and if they're used it can be a gamble. If they're brand new, no need to worry.

As for upkeep, it's best to try and keep them away from light, so I keep them in my closet in a dark corner. A cabinet works too but ensure it's not in any direct sunlight. Next, away from heat and humidity. This means don't leave them outside or in your bathroom, the heat and humidity of the steam in the bathroom will kill the fragrance. Keep them dry in a controlled climate, and definitely not in somewhere like a fridge, the cold will mess with the fragrance oils. Next is try to keep them in the box between uses with the cap on so air doesn't get in or out, primarily an issue with splash bottles. Finally, try not to shake them too often. This isn't an issue if you leave them at home, but if you bring something on travel, make sure it's your designated travel scent and not your more expensive options.

I do hang onto a few I don't like for a short while to come back to them and get a second look. Sometimes letting them age and breathe a bit can change the scent a bit and could be nice. If I really don't like something, I'll give it away to someone who appreciates it, throw it out if it's cheap or genuinely foul/spoiled, or I'll hold it for a resell.

As for others opinions? Well, I am single, but in general I don't care much what people think. Compliments are nice, complaints don't bother me. I wear what pleases my nose and suits occasions. The only people I will take into consideration is my mother and grandfather because they love to complain about what they don't enjoy and declare they have sensitive noses, or are allergic, which is code speak for them not liking something, so I'll wear something I still like and they can tolerate as a compromise.

As for comments here, I love them. I enjoy interaction and reading others thoughts unless it's intentionally meant to rage bait. I only review what I feel and know with honesty.
 
I think you don't like Nutmeg. That note never sat right with me apart from one sole fragrance, and that was because it was in the back behind a wall of notes to give it a slightly powdery aromatic smell.
Possible, all i can really say is it is more offensive than pleasant but it does evolve a bit so its not all bad.

If you want to start a journey with no end dive into the various Vetiver based scents. I used to say as a general rule I like/liked vetiver but as I explored the world of possibilities I found I didn't enjoy them all. The ever popular "Grey Vetiver" from Tom Ford and classic, very green, Guerlain Vetiver are obvious choice. But as you explore the differnt options the results run the spectrum from deep and smokey to super green or floral. I have gotten my hands on very concentrated oils/atar's from India and am very surprised by how different they all are. A nice version of smokey, dark and earthy vetiver is Encre Noir and one I like quite a bit is Montale Red Vetiver. Although I would say the Red Vetiver is a bit more "alive", I am not sure if it is part of the intended notes but I pick up as much pink peppercorn as anything else (I like pink peppercorn). I find Creed's original vetiver a bit disapointing but I imagine it is a very approachable scent for most.
 
Possible, all i can really say is it is more offensive than pleasant but it does evolve a bit so its not all bad.

If you want to start a journey with no end dive into the various Vetiver based scents. I used to say as a general rule I like/liked vetiver but as I explored the world of possibilities I found I didn't enjoy them all. The ever popular "Grey Vetiver" from Tom Ford and classic, very green, Guerlain Vetiver are obvious choice. But as you explore the differnt options the results run the spectrum from deep and smokey to super green or floral. I have gotten my hands on very concentrated oils/atar's from India and am very surprised by how different they all are. A nice version of smokey, dark and earthy vetiver is Encre Noir and one I like quite a bit is Montale Red Vetiver. Although I would say the Red Vetiver is a bit more "alive", I am not sure if it is part of the intended notes but I pick up as much pink peppercorn as anything else (I like pink peppercorn). I find Creed's original vetiver a bit disapointing but I imagine it is a very approachable scent for most.
Another thing to note about vetiver is it often is held in much higher a standard than most other notes, comparable to oud. A lot of fragrances that have Vetiver in the name is annoyingly overpriced or perceived as more luxurious than it is.

In my opinion, vetiver isn't impressive anymore when you start to explore classic mens fragrances and it's almost everywhere in some form. It's just a sweet, smokey, semi-suede note. It's not too special.

Which is upsetting because Bois De Vetiver by Jacques Bogart practically doesn't exist because people bought them all out for this silly vetiver hype. As a fan and collector, it's upsetting to say the least.
 
@CBLindsay further on Nutmeg. That stuff makes or breaks a fragrance. Stuff like British Sterling and Paul Sebastian is very upsetting to my nose.

If you want to try one fragrance with it, as in the only one I like and can wear/tolerate, try Cacharel Pour L'Homme EDT. My bottle is a more recent formulation with the cheap clear plastic cap but still smells very nice. It's classified as a Woody Spicy fragrance, but I feel it's more of a Spicy Citrus Aromatic. It opens with a heavy combo of Bitter Bergamot rind and Ylang Ylang that is backed with nutmeg, but it's not the baby powdery and offensive kind. It's almost lipstick/make up-ish but in a very pleasant manner that slowly devolves into a floral woodiness.

I like the modern but haven't tried the vintage, which would have a metal cap. It may have a stronger nutmeg note so be warned. One thing I can compliment about it is that even though it's a 3.4 the atomizer blasts out like a cannon and since it's not too strong you can over spray a little and burn out a bottle quickly (a plus for a collector-user). I recommend for spring, fall, and summer night time usage. Better in cooler but not cold weather. 1000005390.jpg
 
Funny you mention Paul Sebastian. I remember my dad buying some when I was in my early teens and I liked it very much. I bought us both some about 10 years ago and I simply can't stand it. Not sure if its a new vs "vintage" formulation thing or maybe a concetration (EdP vs EdC) or what but its not the same. Around the same time my dad introduced us all to the PS he bought some Bill Blass (mr blass) and I liked it, so I bought some of that too about 10 years ago and I actually STILL like it.
Thanks for suggesting the nutmeg might be my issue, I now have something I can use to judge a blind buy. It seems Tom Ford Grey Vetiver has a nutmeg middle note, while I dont dislike or find it offensive I put the Grey Vetiver in the "meh" category. could it be the nutmeg?
 
Funny you mention Paul Sebastian. I remember my dad buying some when I was in my early teens and I liked it very much. I bought us both some about 10 years ago and I simply can't stand it. Not sure if its a new vs "vintage" formulation thing or maybe a concetration (EdP vs EdC) or what but its not the same. Around the same time my dad introduced us all to the PS he bought some Bill Blass (mr blass) and I liked it, so I bought some of that too about 10 years ago and I actually STILL like it.
Thanks for suggesting the nutmeg might be my issue, I now have something I can use to judge a blind buy. It seems Tom Ford Grey Vetiver has a nutmeg middle note, while I dont dislike or find it offensive I put the Grey Vetiver in the "meh" category. could it be the nutmeg?
Only way to find out is sample similar fragrances, one with nutmeg, the other without. Only way to tell.
 
1000001326.jpg
Review No 9: Bogart (Signature) by Jacques Bogart

It has been a long few weeks since I did a review, so I thought I ought to do a series on what is slowly becoming one of my favorite fragrance houses, one that's been around a long while with lots of "hit or miss" fragrances. This house has helped me realize my style and taste of fragrances, which appears that I have a nose for cheaper men's classics (called "Drug Store Classics" due to their affordability and being easily found in drug stores) and I have especially noticed I have a taste for french fragrances with a general disdain for Italian fragrances. Ironic given my German roots (that was a joke). So, this one I discovered AFTER a fragrance channel I watch mentioned his love for One Man Show (the original one) and liking Jacques Bogart in general. In fact, this one isn't my first Bogart fragrance, but is among my favorites!

So, this came out in 1975 and was made for the House of Bogart by Maurice Martin. Fun fact, Jacques Bogart isn't a real person but a brand name. The supposed founders are Marcel and Robert Bensoussan, brothers and businessmen. One thing to keep in mind is that Jacques Bogart is a brand exclusively made for men, I mean, it's their whole identity. They set out to make a line of fragrances that are maculine, strong, long lasting, and affordable which is still held to this day, but the "strong" tagline is muddled, as now the brand was sold to an arabian marketing firm in the 2010s or so and have had their ingredients altered. ANYWAY, Bogart by JB was their very, very first fragrance, complete with the EDT, aftershave, and an incredibly rare "After Sport" Splash that doesn't exist, in fact, it no longer exists period! This was actually discontinued! A real shame, because I love this. It's a total powerhouse, and is among the rare few fragrances that didn't have a strong lavender lead or any musk!

So, lets discuss the scent and notes. I won't just write them down, but show you the photo!
1000001327.jpg
Compared to later fragrances from them, the amount of notes are pretty reasonable!

So the top is a simple combination of rosemary and citruses and boy, it starts strong. The top is very heavy and sharp on the rosemary, and then the overal green-citrus follows. I don't get much of the orange but it does have a sweetness that heightens the semi-floral lemon blossom. Then the middle is a spicy fresh combination. The nutmeg really isn't there but you get a healthy dose of clove spice, juniper, and gernaium. (Take note of this! Bogart LOVES including Geranium in almost all their fragrances. It might just be their... Signature. Heh...) Now, if there is lavender, it's hardly there, but the cedar appears as it leads to a base of oakmoss, birch, and leather. This ends beautifully with a woody, spicy, and somewhat "burnt" smell, and if you are all familiar with oakmoss, you know the smell I'm talking about. The leather is there but is a strangely... "Fresh" take on leather. It smells like walking into a Boot Barn or a local leather shop that's been around forever. It smells like freshly made off the shelf boots. It almost has a pine like scent throughout with it's fresh and woody blend at the end. Everything smells realistic and high quality despite it's intended sales for cheap drugstore marketing.

Notably, this lasts a very long time. 5-6 hours outdoors, maybe 6-8 indoors if you work in a cool office. Projects well too. It might fill a room if you spray it on and linger, but after it projects in about a 4 foot aura with a light trail meaning you will be noticed. Outside, it really performs about double because of the heat and sweat.

Now, this scent is incredible. The best way I can describe it is that it smells like Irish Springs, but someone really, really loved the soap and wanted to make love to a bar. The Rosemary is the main reason for this, but everything else is an absolute love letter. Now, I don't know which batch or version, but I DO know this is recent enough to still smell incredible, yet an old enough formulation that it still included naturally sourced fragrance oils. I know this as I am allergic to birch, and as I wear this, the combination of oakmoss and birch makes my throat a little itchy. A curse, but one I can tolerate as it isn't restrictiing my ability to breathe. You may say "read the box" but that won't work. I bought my bottle without a box, and the box I got is a replacement that a seller included in one of my orders because I asked, and was spending a bit.

Anyway, this is perfect for any age period. Old or young, this is fresh as a field, fresh as an Irish Spring. Yes, it's old, but timeless in my eyes and to my nose. This is excellent for Spring and cooler Summer days. This could be worn just about anywhere but it does lean sporty, so going out or playing a sport, or going to the country club works perfectly, but is totally safe for work if no one is allergic. This just evokes maturity and being clean and could easily be a signature scent if someone wanted it to be, and would also please fans of Polo Green. It smells like this is what a Polo Green sport flanker would smell like, if Polo Sport hadn't been made. I would love for this to make a comeback in the market with synthetic oils, which might cheapen the scent but also remove the issue of allergens. I would get the aftershave, but the aftershave was discontinued years before the EDT, meaning they're all vintage with those more natural fragrance oils. I would prefer not to splash that on my face or neck and put the oakmoss and birch point blank under my nostrils and on top of my most sensitive skin areas, but the EDT would be just fine for now.

If anyone did want it, you can still find it on Ebay and such but is way overpriced now. A shame for a classic cheapie, but it will be missed with the high hope of a return for the next generation.
 
Last edited:
1000001329.jpg
Review No. 10: One Man Show EDT by Jacques Bogart

So! Here's the second one made by Bogart, One Man Show, made in 1980, only 5 years later! Now, this review will be a bit briefer as I am not quite a fan of this smell. I know, shocking, but I think it's not as timeless as Bogart Signature. This is their Poster Child scent that just won't go away and is not only still being made to this day, but even has it's aftershave still being made! (Thanks arabian company.)

The notes... Uh, well
1000001330.jpg
Yeah, the notes. Welcome to the 80s where stuff had 20 notes and not one of them can be picked apart, which makes this review difficult. This is supposedly a "Woody Chyphre"... I can try my best but this will be brief. The top is strong. Hard to tell what is really there but it's definitely green and woody. I suspect it's the Caraway, Rosewood, and Galbanum, as in a later flanker that uses Galbanum I can find it and pick it out. The middle is a pissy pine and soap smell. I want to be more precise but really, that's it. The pine and spices mix into an aromatic and complex composure with the labandum and rose making that soapy, poopy floral musk, with a touch of sweetness from the vetiver. Oh look, there's nutmeg, yuck, you can find it if you look for it in this one. The ending is a traincrash of whatever masculine and sweet notes they had on hand. I mean, dude... There's coconut and vanilla that is undetectable in the storm of scents mixing. I can say I could detect the leather, woods, and castoreum mixing with amber, a sweet musk, but thats about it. I have a sharp nose but I can't smell the oakmoss (my beloved) and the other stuff is written but not found. It's a strong, dank, woody, soapy, and yet also an awkwardly sweet concoction.

I really don't enjoy this. To me, it does smell like an old man on his way out. It's like... A urinal cake smell mixing with cheap bathroom air freshener. It gives me a headche. It's not as strong as the original formulation (thank God). It can last way longer than you expect, I'd say about 7 hours hot or cold. I highly reccomend fall and winter usage. In the heat this will be much too cloying and will stink up a joint. Projection is about 6 feet or more if hot. Some really macho guys like this stuff and make claims about it being a masterpiece, but I think otherwise. This is something guys wore in the 80s to be loud and annoying to cut the stank of cigars and cheap alcohol or wanting to make a statement in executive meetings. I am shocked OMS original outlived Bogart and is being worn. I know taste is subjective but bad taste is still bad taste. I can say I have bad taste too, to be fair, but this isn't something I can really say has a place in todays fragrance economy. I can say this would be liked by fans of vintage Brut and Polo but want something stronger or much more raw.

I know I'm being harsh, but I have to be honest with my feelings, gentleman or not. My fragrance reviewer I watch, Scents of South Jersey, is a cool guy, but sometimes he has bad taste (sorry Kelan!) and I usually like what he doesn't, which is funny. Well, if you want to try it, don't take my words as gospel, you can find it cheap cheap online, even with a sample tube of the aftershave!

Maybe I should open up my mercari to sell the stuff I don't like for you guys...
 
Last edited:
1000001332.jpg
Review No. 11: One Man Show Gold Edition by Jacques Bogart

Ah so here's something I wanted to mention. I wanted to go in chronological order what I have by Jacques Bogart, but I can't just mention OMS and not also bring up it's 5 flankers. Yes, there are 6 versions of One Man Show, if you can believe it. What's even more striking is that OMS original was solo until 2011 when OMS Gold came out! That is literally 31 years of existence until it had a brother! And I can say wholeheartedly that it was quite worth the wait! This is the first flanker to come and it truly feels like a flanker to the orginal from the notes to the scent itself, and yet I find myself liking this one a lot more than the original. In fact, I even wear it from time to time. This was made as a "limited edition" for their over 30 years of making fragrance, and limited was a lie, they made A LOT of this stuff for way longer than what should be reasonable and you can still pick up a bottle for cheap on ebay if you wanted.

The good and bad thing about this thing's design is that they kept the original design of the bottle, the iconic tall rectangle with a built in sprayer, and the 4 lines on the side of the box with the reflective sticker. Funny thing about french fragrances is they often have that "proof of authenticity" sticker you'll see here and there on the classics. Even Ted Lapidus still does it, and Guy Laroche used to do it at one point! The bad thing is this obnoxious matte black bottle. It's first of all called "Gold" edition and yet there's hardly any gold outside of the box, second is that the matte black would have looked nicer if it was just a clear black bottle so you can see the juice inside. I have debated with myself on literally scraping the matte layer like I have with my small bottle of Polo Supreme Oud... Besides that, great presentation. I have grown a love for these old style built in sprayer bottles, something about them feels like vintage sci-fi and cyberpunkish, like if you saw an advertisement bearing this bottle style, or see it on the desk/table in a room in a sci-fi movie, it would blend right in! And thankfully, Jacques Bogart typically kept this bottle style as the years went on, as if some executive or their marketing agent put up a fight like the owner of costco and threatened death if anyone dared to alter their iconic silhouettes.

Anyway, the notes! Oh and hey, take a shot every time you see a Jacques Bogart fragrance that contains Geranium/Labdandum. You might die of alcohol poisoning by the 5th fragrance.
1000001334.jpg
So yeah, you see it has quite a few notes but compared to OMS original this is much more coherent and you can identify some stuff. It also carries a lot of the original DNA and remixes it by adding new stuff to make it a real flanker or alternative edition. So, this stuff starts off with a BLAST of synthetic juicy red apple, scented more towards the smell of the apple's skin, as if you had peeled it off with a pocket knife and it still had some apple "meat" go with it. This is heightened and pushed by a sharp floral violet and anise combination, and the violet isn't your typical "old school" soapy or powdery violet, this is more of a raw manly violet, mixed with that sharp anise in the back for a rounded sweet, raw, and floral opening. I cannot detect any of the orange/orange flower whatsoever so it may have fallen somewhere in the background. Now as that fades in about 5-10 minutes we have the heart of the fragrance is this is where it gets interesting. The musk in the base and the violet musk somehow blend and overhaul/override the middle, but I can say that the Cinnamon and Clove do stand out. The style we have is less of a sweetened, totally grated powdery spice, but the Cinnamon smells like Cinnamon oil, that sharp, strong, and spicy kind that you feel in your throat, unlike Calvin Kleins powdery Cinnamon. The Clove is noticeable but not unpleasant, and the clove lends a nice sweet and light powdery touch. The lavender is absent but I think you can find the Geranium in the mix somewhere is you can dig for it. You need to smell Geranium on it's own to train your nose to find it. This wraps up on a nice, musky amber base. It is slightly animalic but overall pleasant as the Show ends on a Musk and Amber lead, with a woody soapy undertone given by the famous Labdanum. The wood here is the generic "woody notes" you'll see in cheap fragrances, but to my nose I believe it's a Cedar and Oak mixture, as that sharp birchness is absent at the end. Somewhere you can find some wafting, blink and you miss it moments that reminds you of the original OMS, possibly from the few carried over notes, but it also might be the alcohol they use. It's hard to describe but if you wear OMS for a period of time then smell this right after, you'll pick up on it.

So this is a very nice, simple, but also somewhat young musk amber scent. Usually when you wear a Jacques Bogart scent it carries a mature and dated appeal but this is very young and fresh compared to their older and later additons. One thing I can't understand is this gets compared to stuff like YSL Kouros and Lapidus pour homme. This notion is preposterous and uninformed. Why do I say this with confidence? Because I OWN both of them and have worn them enough to tell you this is a lie. In fact, if someone wants to point fingers and make a comparision, look to Furyō by Jacques Bogart, which is their closest answer to Kouros. Kouros is a pissy and extremely animalic Aromatic Fougere with no sweetness. Oh but Lapidus is also a sweet amber musk! WRONG, it's a sweet amber ANIMALIC musk, while this is more just a sweet amber musk, do NOT argue with me. This is what I would imagine a baby of vintage Jōvan Musk Oil and One Man Show would smell like.

Here is proof of ownership.
1000001336.jpg

Anyways, that was not a flex but a vent and to show I know what I am talking about. I will argue until I die. Each of these have their place, some in the grave, and others in a furnace. Performace wise, OMS Gold will last you a steady 5 hours or so, it's mostly because of the ingedient quality, but it does make for a nice skin scent at the end. It projects pretty well but is meant for cold weather and winter, trust me. You will get noticed downwind but if you're in a room, a safe 4 or so feet radius with a possible double in size if the room is warm. This is a very approachable musk scent you can envision wearing with a cozy sweater and won't scare of kids and women alike.

Try it for yourself if you want a "baby's first" animalic totest the waters. I consider musk and animalic in two different catergories, as does fragrantica and parfumo, and this is a good starting point. It's more musk and less animalic and is a great baseline. If you want something stronger, go to lapidus. Even stronger? Kouros because it's still around, but if you got the bread, Furyō. If you don't like it, take a step back into musk with stuff like Obsession or Jovan musk, there are plenty of options.
 
Last edited:
Review No. 12: One Man Show Ruby Edition
1000001333.jpg
So here it is, One Man Show number 3, the "red one". This came out in 2013, so two years later between releases and this one, as you see, does do the clear bottle. It is ridiculously red. Besides that, this one is generally disliked and is very "Love it or hate it", or you like it one day, dislike it the next. I intitally really wanted to enjoy it but something just... Didn't stick out to me in a way that made me WANT it. This one does the mistake of making a flanker OF a flanker and straying too far from the original idea. This intends to be a sweet and romantic smell, but comes off as an "old man's" attempt to replicate what kids these days are wearing. It wants to be a flanker to OMS Gold but just changed too much and didn't live up to the Jacques Bogart spirit.

Here's the notes
1000001337.jpg
So wow, this is very, very simple, but also odd. The top is a very strong sweet lavender and juicy green apple combo with no real presence of the orange leaf. It somewhat attempts to smell like something that would be worn today, a lavender bomb that you'd see in CH Bad Boy, or Invictus flanker, and other similar things. The heart of Incence and Ladbandum sticks out as a sweet and smoky combo. The saffron is there but hard to really pick out because the other notes really drown it out. The base is a sickly, sticky sweet honey and cedar combo, with the oud not even really existing to my nose, and I am an oud fan! It's something mentioned but never seen.

This one is a very, very sweet synthetic mess that somewhat smells like a cheap red wine/flavored mead. I know this is intended for men but I think someone intended this to secretly be for women. I am not saying that to at all disrespect the fragrance, but the notes here are often found in womens fragrances, and if you see the reviews, a lot of women use this or use it as a layering base. Funny huh, as this was intended to be a macho "men's only" brand and yet here we are. I believe they wanted this to be a date night scent but it just flopped. Lots of guys passed on it and it was pretty unremarkable.

Strength-wise, it projects well enough for about 4 feet at 4 hours. This is a short ride and one that isn't too exciting and can be headache inducing. If you want a very, very sickly sweet men's fragrance, here you go. I had to pass on this one.
 
1000001347.jpg
Lucky Review No. 13: One Man Show Oud Edition EDT

I don't need to tell anyone how much I LOVE this fragrance. I wear it often and members will recognize me praising this frequently in the daily fragrance thread and for good reason. This is an excellent cheap, masculine fragrance that almost smells niche, yet is so simple. If you love leather and oud, I cannot reccomend this any further. This wasn't my first Jacques Bogart fragrance, nor was it my first Oud, but it was the first one of each that I absolutely loved. I mean, the oud here isn't all that loud or dominant but waht it does is heighten the experience with an earthy, woody touch. I can say I love everything about it as well, from scent to presentation, especially that dark, clear brown glass. This feels like a true flanker to the orignal OMS... Ugh let me stop gloating and tell you about the damn thing!

The Notes:
1000001343.jpg
What you see here is a very simple, but very effect 9 note fragrance, which is pretty simple, yet it has some complexities, You've seen just about everything here but the Oud and Papyrus really seal the deal to make this a great scent, differentiating it from most other similar fragrances of it's variety. To start, the top is a heavy, aromatic burst of Galbanum and hints of Clary Sage with a mild, absent Bergamot, which is a nice inversion to the normal blueprint Bergeamot being front and center, yet within moments this strong aromacy is overtaken by a unique "burnt hair" aroma. I believe this may be a spice hidden in the middle coming out rapidly, or maybe the alcohol effects the oils but this is a very very common thing mentioned by all who use this scent. It's not bad or gag inducing, but very odd. Soon the middle comes in in a very interesting take on oud. The oud here is incredibly woody and subtly earthy, with the "burnt hair" spice being present, and the Geranium is surprsingly quiet here, yet there is an odd... "Baby wipe" smell that may arise on some skin types but is usually absent on clothes. The Geranium is not absent nor undetectable but it does it's work in the shadows to heighten the woody oud spice. This middle carries into an immaculate drydown in the base. The oud loses it's woody character and starts to remain spicy and earthy, more than likely from the patchouli and we're now left with a smoldering, "burnt" spicy leather scent, in which the papyrus is very, VERY loud as it lends it's dry, burning paper note to the dark aged leather. This is where all the compliments are and is when it's at it's most noticeable. Issue is, this is what I call a "man's man" fragrance, where you will get noticed, complimented, and asked about by other men, but women are usually quiet and left puzzled or quietly intrigued. This is a very "Self enjoyed" fragrance built for a man.

I cannot understate my love of this fragrance and don't want to spend too long articulating it. It's dark, sophisticated, yet simple. It's warm and alluring but also can be apprehensice. This is meant for the cooler weather or hot nights for a bold approach and will last roughly 4-5 hours with a mild projection of about 3-4 feet but leaves quite a trail. Now, my bottle isn't new anymore and has aged into perfection, but I do recall a brand new bottle with about 3 sprays could fill a small room. I have been told when I apply in the restroom (so I don't disturb the breakroom) it literaly for several minutes and supposedly has a warm sweet smell... Odd, but nice.

I highly, highty reccomend those with simple but bold taste to pick up a bottle whenever able. You can find it just about anywhere for cheap, with the lowest I've seen being at 10 bucks brand new. One downside is that there is no aftershave but there is a deodorant spray, an upside is you can pair this easily with a bayrum or musk aftershave, or even a layer if you want. This isn't at all animalic, but you can make it be.

How I discovered this was actually by a random stranger I met at a TJ Maxx and we were both checking the fragrance shelf and just started an hour long conversation and he said "hey, if you like masculine stuff from the 80s, and oud, try OMS Oud. It's strong and will stand out in a crowd. It's the kinda scent people in the 80s would wear to cut over the stench of cigars and cheap whiskey." And with that, wear it with a cigar, it should pair nicely!
 
View attachment 155265
Lucky Review No. 13: One Man Show Oud Edition EDT

I don't need to tell anyone how much I LOVE this fragrance. I wear it often and members will recognize me praising this frequently in the daily fragrance thread and for good reason. This is an excellent cheap, masculine fragrance that almost smells niche, yet is so simple. If you love leather and oud, I cannot reccomend this any further. This wasn't my first Jacques Bogart fragrance, nor was it my first Oud, but it was the first one of each that I absolutely loved. I mean, the oud here isn't all that loud or dominant but waht it does is heighten the experience with an earthy, woody touch. I can say I love everything about it as well, from scent to presentation, especially that dark, clear brown glass. This feels like a true flanker to the orignal OMS... Ugh let me stop gloating and tell you about the damn thing!

The Notes:
View attachment 155266
What you see here is a very simple, but very effect 9 note fragrance, which is pretty simple, yet it has some complexities, You've seen just about everything here but the Oud and Papyrus really seal the deal to make this a great scent, differentiating it from most other similar fragrances of it's variety. To start, the top is a heavy, aromatic burst of Galbanum and hints of Clary Sage with a mild, absent Bergamot, which is a nice inversion to the normal blueprint Bergeamot being front and center, yet within moments this strong aromacy is overtaken by a unique "burnt hair" aroma. I believe this may be a spice hidden in the middle coming out rapidly, or maybe the alcohol effects the oils but this is a very very common thing mentioned by all who use this scent. It's not bad or gag inducing, but very odd. Soon the middle comes in in a very interesting take on oud. The oud here is incredibly woody and subtly earthy, with the "burnt hair" spice being present, and the Geranium is surprsingly quiet here, yet there is an odd... "Baby wipe" smell that may arise on some skin types but is usually absent on clothes. The Geranium is not absent nor undetectable but it does it's work in the shadows to heighten the woody oud spice. This middle carries into an immaculate drydown in the base. The oud loses it's woody character and starts to remain spicy and earthy, more than likely from the patchouli and we're now left with a smoldering, "burnt" spicy leather scent, in which the papyrus is very, VERY loud as it lends it's dry, burning paper note to the dark aged leather. This is where all the compliments are and is when it's at it's most noticeable. Issue is, this is what I call a "man's man" fragrance, where you will get noticed, complimented, and asked about by other men, but women are usually quiet and left puzzled or quietly intrigued. This is a very "Self enjoyed" fragrance built for a man.

I cannot understate my love of this fragrance and don't want to spend too long articulating it. It's dark, sophisticated, yet simple. It's warm and alluring but also can be apprehensice. This is meant for the cooler weather or hot nights for a bold approach and will last roughly 4-5 hours with a mild projection of about 3-4 feet but leaves quite a trail. Now, my bottle isn't new anymore and has aged into perfection, but I do recall a brand new bottle with about 3 sprays could fill a small room. I have been told when I apply in the restroom (so I don't disturb the breakroom) it literaly for several minutes and supposedly has a warm sweet smell... Odd, but nice.

I highly, highty reccomend those with simple but bold taste to pick up a bottle whenever able. You can find it just about anywhere for cheap, with the lowest I've seen being at 10 bucks brand new. One downside is that there is no aftershave but there is a deodorant spray, an upside is you can pair this easily with a bayrum or musk aftershave, or even a layer if you want. This isn't at all animalic, but you can make it be.
Hmmm.. May have to pick up a bottle of this. :unsure:
 
Hmmm.. May have to pick up a bottle of this. :unsure:
10 bucks brand new on mercari... before the 8 dollar shipping... and tax... on ebay it's a bit over 20 bucks, and other online stores is between 12-16 bucks but you have to add tax with shipping and handling unless you do a bigger order for free shipping and a payment plan. I can always supply a link!
 
1000001348.jpg
Review No. 14: One Man Show Emerald Edition EDT

So. Here's where we get back to the "Flanker of a flanker" nonsense that Ruby had come up with. This right here had A LOT of potentional, fragrance-wise, but falls very short of expectation. See, this is, or was, intended to be a straight up "Green" fragrance, but somehow they get this wrong despite the fact they had made the legendary Bogart Signature and One Man Show. The clear Green bottle is defintely cool, but is hard to look at and is reminiscent of Ruby Edition. This came out in 2018 so very, very late in the game. Anyway, this is practically a remix of Ruby edition and a watered down and diluted version of the original OMS. I was expecting something stronger, but... Well...

Here's the notes.
1000001346.jpg
So. Take a look. You see what I mean when I say this had potentional? This top starts immediately with an awkward blast of sweetened Elemi that almost instantly morphs into a sweet and soapy violet instead of the sharper violet from Gold edition, with Basil being missing in action. This slowly opens the middle and it's obnoxiously dominated by the nutmeg and not leaving much room for the cedar to breathe, as the tonka bean slowly arises, but it's a sweeter cashmere-esque tonka instead of a spicier tonka. At the end we're left with an earthy, soapy blend of labdanum and patchouli with a very quiet, absent leather. This scent ends up too sweet and mellow, boring even. This smells like an old man attempting to make a modern green fragrance for a different brand instead of making a modern green for Jacques Bogart. Note: Reminiscent of dryer sheets.

This fragrance is an easy pass in my book unless you're looking for a very simple, quiet, and tolerable green fragrance you can wear at any time. The projection is very, very weak, about 2-3 feet with no sillage, but it will last surprisingly long, about 6 hours. I can also mention is you spray on clothes and wear this under a coat, the leather and violet really dominates the fragrance, which is odd. Fortunately this is very, very cheap. I think to improve it would just move the elemi to the middle and swap the nutmeg for clove, then move the cedar to the top. Odd, yes, but to me elemi, which is a tree sap, doesn't work as a top note.
 
1000001352.jpg
Review No 15: One Man Show 24k Editon EDP

And here we are. Every good Show must come to an end, even the best ones do. This is my very, very first OMS fragrance that I have bought and wore, fitting here as it is the last of the OMS line, and was also the very most recent release from Jacques Bogart in 2023, and after 3 years, nothing, which leaves a pretty ominous feeling. I know they made several other fragrances, and had made the Silver Scent line, but not even that has had a recent release, so we're left with the culmination of their effort. This is what I consider the true anniversary fragrance and pinnacle of the Jacques Bogart brand. Besides it's stunning gold bottle in contrast to the black and gold "Gold Edition" bottle, this is their first and ONLY EDP, it's challenging yet masculine, and it comes off more valuable than it really is.

Here's the notes!
1000001351.jpg
So, to be simple and blunt, for their first and only EDP, this is obviously very middle eastern inspired, which makes sense as they are owned by a middle eastern company. The top is a shockingly strong opening of a sweet and juicy tangerine that is coated in pink pepper, with the cardamom being in the back giving a warmth, yet is missing it's infamous "underarm" type odor. This follows a trend of fruity Jacques Bogart fragrances from the past in the mid 2000s so this is a very pleasant and intriguing homage in a sense. This smoothly transitions into a very, very bizarre middle. See, there is rose there, with saffron and- Oh, look. Geranium. Can't make your first ever EDP without it, you slick dogs. But anyway, it has all that and usually you would expect to really smell the rose, but here, very, very oddly, this is a very saffron and geranium dominated middle. It's an oddly spicy, planty-green floral with the rose SOMEHOW, by SOME MIRACLE, being buried in the back to add a touch of powdery sweetness. Eventually, we come to the ending and it's great, the best part. You have here the same "burnt hair" oud from OMS Oud Edition, paired with sandalwood and amber, and the very odd note of Nagarmotha. So, the oud is obviously here, you can detect it thoughout the fragrance but the sandalwood is also very present during the mid, and the amber adds a balancing powdery sweetness over this oddly sharp woody note in the back. It's a very middle eastern oud payoff here.

So, to put it in a blunt sense, this essentially smells like all the One Man Show's combined, stripping all their best elements and combining them into one. There is a very unique sweet, woody, smokiness to it also.

So, strength wise, it doesn't project too crazily, approximately 4 feet but has good sillage, but this thing lasts all damn day, running the mile for 8 hours just about especially on clothes. Do wear on cooler weather, it is excellent for fall and can work in winter, and allows for an extra spray or two. I will say this smells as if it was a literal EDP flanker to Oud Edition, so if anyone of you buy and like One Man Show Oud Edition, you might like this as it's "intense" interpretation for more intimate scenarios. I would have liked the leather to be here but it's fine without it.

And this will send off my One... Well, SIX man show. I feel sad it ends here with this. I would have liked to have seen, funnily enough, more flankers like a Silver Edition, Platinum Edition, but most interesting to me would be if they had made a "Sapphire" Edition which would be an interesting look at how Jacques Bogart would try to make a fresh "Blue" fragrance under the OMS label. But, luckily, they have made 30 other fragrances and Silver Scent, their other signature like, has in fact made 2 or 3 blue fragrances so I may look into those at some point in the future. Up next are my other oddballs, see you soon.
 
Back
Top