No way I can commit to a list of 5 but I do have a few favs.
Chiseled Face ghost town barber (LOVE it)
Eufros Rosa Bourbon (or CBL Rosa bourbon)
Orange Dirt (CBL or Fine Accoutrements)
Vetiver...love the different vetiver scents
Long rifle voyager is a lovely scent I would hate to be without (the scent is light but I like it)
* aside from particular scents I love strong, prominent scents. PannaCrema Nuavia, Saponificio Verasino, Fine, CBL, Chambers, and declaration grooming come to mind as being strong or prominent.