I’ve been dipping back into the world of badgers after a long hiatus. I also was disillusioned with them after growing to dislike an AOS brush. Comparatively, the very first synthetic I picked up felt nicer, lathered better, and was easier to get along with. Finally, thanks to a couple better than average badger knots, I’m enjoying them again!
I think synthetics have the upper hand in most qualities such as ease of use and maintenance, while badgers, even great ones, excel over synthetics only in face feel.
In general, I’ve observed that any new badger brushes for less than $50, you’re kind of rolling the dice on how “good” the knot will be; $50-$100 will generally get you into the “good enough” tier of badgers where some folks stay, happy that the knots are good enough to not need to shell out for better; then $150+ seems to get you into the higher end tier, where it’s generally expected that you’re getting near perfection when it comes to a badger, along with a certain uniqueness in handle. Now, there are some exceptions if you have a highly regarded hobbyist like
@Smattayu and the ability to source yourself a knot from TGN or Whipped Dog (
@CBLindsay actually talked about this a little in his last shave video).
The BST in a trusted forum will be your best bang for your buck for well-regraded name brand brushes, even though it will be slightly used. Alternatively I might recommend waiting and working with a hobbyist like
@Smattayu or
@Graydog to get your handle and do some research on sourcing our own knot from a reputable vendor, which should save you some cash over buying name brand.