The Shaving Cadre
Welcome to The Shaving Cadre, a forum dedicated to gentlemanly discourse about wet shaving and other topics of common interests. Membership is always free so register today and join in the fun
Mystic May
- Thread starter Spider
- Start date
remfan170
Shave Newbie
I really love CBL's Russian Tea. What scents do you like? His aftershave is so good I rarely use a balm when I use it.
You talked me into buying this soap after we talked over at the other place. I have been using Williams and some other soaps so this is really the second soap I ever had in the den.
remfan170
Shave Newbie
Congratulations!
Thank you!
remfan170
Shave Newbie
love the pinaud musk!
remfan170
Shave Newbie
May 3, 2026 (Mystic May Every Other Day)
• Brush: Semogue – 2000 (Boar)
• Razor: Eldrormr Industries – MM24
• Blade: Accuforge – GEM Microcoat
• Soap: Mystic Water – Rosalimone
• Aftershave: Talent Soap Factory – Fragrance Free Aftershave
• Balm: Stirling – Unscented Post Shave Balm
• Fragrance: Mystic Water – Rosalimone Perfume Oil
Michelle Burns, the charming and talented woman behind Mystic Water, spent time living in Sardinia, Italy and this has had a profound influence on many of the products that she creates. I see it in her respect for terroir and ingredients. I also see it in the confidence she has to simply let a single scent (or two) speak for itself. As our friend, @wyzeone, reflected yesterday in his wonderful review of her Lily of the Valley soap, she has the ability to create a focused and natural smelling soliflore (thank you, wyze, for teaching me that concept). She also has the ability to create scents that are redolent and evoke landscapes in Italy.
Just looking at her shave soaps, we can see it in Maestrale, which, she notes, “is the name of the bracing wind that brings fresh, clear weather to the island of Sardinia, where spike lavender, rosemary and peppermint grow wild.” She writes of her Poggio dei Pini: “This scent reminds me of hiking on the wooded hills behind my former home in Sardinia, Italy. Poggio means knoll or hill, Poggio dei Pini is literally ‘hill of pines’. It smells of pine and cypress trees, and the dry resinous underbrush of wild plants called the "macchia mediterranea" that grow everywhere, a masculine but subtle outdoors fragrance.” She even has a shave soap called Sardinian Honey, where she “used some of [her] private stash of honey from the Sardinian mountains in this delicately scented light brown soap (the color comes from the honey).”
I believe that Italy also inspired the shave soap I am using today: Rosalimone. She describes this as “a delicate, well balanced pairing of tart lemon peel essential oil and freshly cut roses.” This soap has been an absolute revelation for me. If you would have asked me as late as last year what rose smelled like, I might have thought of rosewater or rosewater Turkish delights. Perhaps I might have thought of a single, red rose. But, most of all, I would have thought of the Golden Girls and my grandmother’s cloying 1980s Rose scent. Rose to me wasn’t just a lady’s scent, it was an old lady’s scent.
Michelle changed all that with Rosalimone and a few other soaps she created (i.e., Earth Rose, Rose Garden, and Yellow Rose). I did not realize just how versatile rose can be as a scent. They are yellow roses, damask roses, and tea roses that have been tempered with other things like lemon or sandalwood.
In Rosalimone, the lemon is indeed tart. But, the rose scent is more than just floral and sweet. It is herbaceous, Earthy, and restrained. The scent is well-balanced and interplay between the two creates something that is exquisite. It almost conforms to what you are doing. It is cooling and bracing if the weather is warm and seems to elevate as it gets dark out. To be able to accomplish something this natural and complex with two scent notes is the work of a true artisan. I’ll be writing about some of the other rose scents as I use them. But, I’ll say this, if you’re after florals, particularly roses, Mystic Water is a great place to go. Her fragrance oils (the roll-on) you see are very potent and at about $9.00, represent some of the greatest value in the world of perfumery I have come across. I will say this often, but it is important. Michelle will do an aftershave of most any of her shaves for about $16.00 and a perfume oil for about $9.00. Just be sure to write to her to ask.
Have an awesome day, friends!
• Brush: Semogue – 2000 (Boar)
• Razor: Eldrormr Industries – MM24
• Blade: Accuforge – GEM Microcoat
• Soap: Mystic Water – Rosalimone
• Aftershave: Talent Soap Factory – Fragrance Free Aftershave
• Balm: Stirling – Unscented Post Shave Balm
• Fragrance: Mystic Water – Rosalimone Perfume Oil
Michelle Burns, the charming and talented woman behind Mystic Water, spent time living in Sardinia, Italy and this has had a profound influence on many of the products that she creates. I see it in her respect for terroir and ingredients. I also see it in the confidence she has to simply let a single scent (or two) speak for itself. As our friend, @wyzeone, reflected yesterday in his wonderful review of her Lily of the Valley soap, she has the ability to create a focused and natural smelling soliflore (thank you, wyze, for teaching me that concept). She also has the ability to create scents that are redolent and evoke landscapes in Italy.
Just looking at her shave soaps, we can see it in Maestrale, which, she notes, “is the name of the bracing wind that brings fresh, clear weather to the island of Sardinia, where spike lavender, rosemary and peppermint grow wild.” She writes of her Poggio dei Pini: “This scent reminds me of hiking on the wooded hills behind my former home in Sardinia, Italy. Poggio means knoll or hill, Poggio dei Pini is literally ‘hill of pines’. It smells of pine and cypress trees, and the dry resinous underbrush of wild plants called the "macchia mediterranea" that grow everywhere, a masculine but subtle outdoors fragrance.” She even has a shave soap called Sardinian Honey, where she “used some of [her] private stash of honey from the Sardinian mountains in this delicately scented light brown soap (the color comes from the honey).”
I believe that Italy also inspired the shave soap I am using today: Rosalimone. She describes this as “a delicate, well balanced pairing of tart lemon peel essential oil and freshly cut roses.” This soap has been an absolute revelation for me. If you would have asked me as late as last year what rose smelled like, I might have thought of rosewater or rosewater Turkish delights. Perhaps I might have thought of a single, red rose. But, most of all, I would have thought of the Golden Girls and my grandmother’s cloying 1980s Rose scent. Rose to me wasn’t just a lady’s scent, it was an old lady’s scent.
Michelle changed all that with Rosalimone and a few other soaps she created (i.e., Earth Rose, Rose Garden, and Yellow Rose). I did not realize just how versatile rose can be as a scent. They are yellow roses, damask roses, and tea roses that have been tempered with other things like lemon or sandalwood.
In Rosalimone, the lemon is indeed tart. But, the rose scent is more than just floral and sweet. It is herbaceous, Earthy, and restrained. The scent is well-balanced and interplay between the two creates something that is exquisite. It almost conforms to what you are doing. It is cooling and bracing if the weather is warm and seems to elevate as it gets dark out. To be able to accomplish something this natural and complex with two scent notes is the work of a true artisan. I’ll be writing about some of the other rose scents as I use them. But, I’ll say this, if you’re after florals, particularly roses, Mystic Water is a great place to go. Her fragrance oils (the roll-on) you see are very potent and at about $9.00, represent some of the greatest value in the world of perfumery I have come across. I will say this often, but it is important. Michelle will do an aftershave of most any of her shaves for about $16.00 and a perfume oil for about $9.00. Just be sure to write to her to ask.
Have an awesome day, friends!
05.03.2026
remfan170
Shave Newbie
May 5, 2026 (Mystic May Every Other Day)
• Bowl: Doug Smith Pottery – Ceramic Shave Bowl
• Brush: Semogue – 1470 (Boar)
• Razor: GEM – Micromatic Open Comb (Second Generation)
• Blade: Accuforge – GEM Microcoat
• Soap: Mystic Water – Bay Rum
• Aftershave: Small Batch Empire NYC 2025 Bay Rum Aftershave
• Balm: Stirling – Unscented Post Shave Balm
• Fragrance: Olympic Orchids – Bay Rum
When I started wetshaving in 2018, I spent some time continuing to use Gillette Foamy and Barbasol (both things I still keep for quick shaves because I like their scent). As I began wetshaving, I worked my way from Proraso to TOBS to MWF for a few years. But, it was really a youtuber named Nickshaves that got me to think about artisans. He was particularly active in the late 2010s and stopped posting just as the pandemic began. He is, from what I can tell, a surgeon, so he does not have a lot of time I suppose. I do miss his content.
Given how much wetshaving artisans have exploded in this decade, going back through his videos and Instagram is to see a lot of brands that were popular years ago. This includes my beloved Mike’s Natural and Mystic Water. In fact, his video on Mystic Water’s Bay Rum is what made me aware of MW and to make my very first purchase from her. Even though his video is from 2015, it, like all of his videos, still hold up today.
I tend to agree with Nickshaves on shave soap performance. It is the sign of a truly great shave soap to protect you from the wonderful GEM MMOC. However, I tend to see scents (particularly bay rum) a bit different than him. Whereas Nick loves MW’s Bay Rum scent and defines it as very masculine, with a strong bay backbone, and “incredible,” I agree that the scent is fantastic, but I am not sure about where Nickshaves is placing his emphases. I tend to see MW’s bay rum scent as a balanced bay rum putting extra emphasis on the jasmine and other notes that tone the pimenta racemosa down a touch.
Overall, MW’s scent is very pleasant and is not aggressive (in terms of the scent itself, the scent strength is up there). As Michelle notes, her “more refined version will appeal to men who don't like the clove that often predominates in bay rum blends.” Fans of Barrister and Mann’s Bay Rum would find this pleasing though the citrus notes are nowhere near as prominent as they are in B&M’s version. The most similar bay rum out there would be Hendrix Classics and Co.’s version, though MW does smell a bit more natural and complex. I encourage folks to give it a try. If you have too many shave soaps, I would try a bar of her bath soap. It is, to my mind, the best on the market and at $6.60 is not that much more per oz. than Stirling.
Have an awesome day, friends!
• Bowl: Doug Smith Pottery – Ceramic Shave Bowl
• Brush: Semogue – 1470 (Boar)
• Razor: GEM – Micromatic Open Comb (Second Generation)
• Blade: Accuforge – GEM Microcoat
• Soap: Mystic Water – Bay Rum
• Aftershave: Small Batch Empire NYC 2025 Bay Rum Aftershave
• Balm: Stirling – Unscented Post Shave Balm
• Fragrance: Olympic Orchids – Bay Rum
When I started wetshaving in 2018, I spent some time continuing to use Gillette Foamy and Barbasol (both things I still keep for quick shaves because I like their scent). As I began wetshaving, I worked my way from Proraso to TOBS to MWF for a few years. But, it was really a youtuber named Nickshaves that got me to think about artisans. He was particularly active in the late 2010s and stopped posting just as the pandemic began. He is, from what I can tell, a surgeon, so he does not have a lot of time I suppose. I do miss his content.
Given how much wetshaving artisans have exploded in this decade, going back through his videos and Instagram is to see a lot of brands that were popular years ago. This includes my beloved Mike’s Natural and Mystic Water. In fact, his video on Mystic Water’s Bay Rum is what made me aware of MW and to make my very first purchase from her. Even though his video is from 2015, it, like all of his videos, still hold up today.
I tend to agree with Nickshaves on shave soap performance. It is the sign of a truly great shave soap to protect you from the wonderful GEM MMOC. However, I tend to see scents (particularly bay rum) a bit different than him. Whereas Nick loves MW’s Bay Rum scent and defines it as very masculine, with a strong bay backbone, and “incredible,” I agree that the scent is fantastic, but I am not sure about where Nickshaves is placing his emphases. I tend to see MW’s bay rum scent as a balanced bay rum putting extra emphasis on the jasmine and other notes that tone the pimenta racemosa down a touch.
Overall, MW’s scent is very pleasant and is not aggressive (in terms of the scent itself, the scent strength is up there). As Michelle notes, her “more refined version will appeal to men who don't like the clove that often predominates in bay rum blends.” Fans of Barrister and Mann’s Bay Rum would find this pleasing though the citrus notes are nowhere near as prominent as they are in B&M’s version. The most similar bay rum out there would be Hendrix Classics and Co.’s version, though MW does smell a bit more natural and complex. I encourage folks to give it a try. If you have too many shave soaps, I would try a bar of her bath soap. It is, to my mind, the best on the market and at $6.60 is not that much more per oz. than Stirling.
Have an awesome day, friends!
fhalden
"Like BarberDave… I make my own fun”
Congratulations on your Daughter's graduation! You did it! I mean, I know she graduated, but a Father deserves some credit for guiding a child through adulthood!