Has anyone tried or used Thayers Milky Toner?

[JanJosh]

So like most here I've used and tried Thayers Witch Hazel and Aloe Toner, love the unscented and just started trying the Rose Petal one, but I see there's a Milky one with Snow Mushroom and Hyaluronic Acid. How's it feel in comparison? Worse or better? Does it mesh well with after shave splashes/balms?

 

[MarkB]

Never tried it but color me intrigued..

 

[JanJosh]

Never tried it but color me intrigued..

I'm curious too but it's also like 13.50-15 bucks compared to 11 bucks for the witch hazel or 4 bucks for the trial sizes

 

[DrC527]

I have a nearly full bottle of original and 80% of a rose petal one. Will try it eventually, but those bottles will probably last me over a year.

 

[Spider]

Never tried it but color me intrigued..

Ditto. I'll definitely be picking up a bottle. I have a WH mix that I use right after my shave, and I'll be adding this to the mix.

 

[Spider]

I just picked these up. So far, pretty good. It's like a thin lotion, slightly thicker than CBL's Aftershave Tonic.

 

[JanJosh]

I just picked these up. So far, pretty good. It's like a thin lotion, slightly thicker than CBL's Aftershave Tonic.
View attachment 159644

Huh. Tell me after experimenting with a few routine alterations how it feels to the toner overall

 

[Spider]

Huh. Tell me after experimenting with a few routine alterations how it feels to the toner overall

It tones and moisturizes. The regular toners dont moisturize.

 

[JanJosh]

It tones and moisturizes. The regular toners dont moisturize.

Yes i know that lol. I meant like sometimes it's just toner and aftershave, others it's alum and toner, etc etc

 

[NurseDave]

I'm curious too but it's also like 13.50-15 bucks compared to 11 bucks for the witch hazel or 4 bucks for the trial sizes

But dude, snow mushroom

 

[BarberDave]

Thayers got rid of Thayers Lemon…..Thayers is dead to me

 

[Spider]

Yes i know that lol. I meant like sometimes it's just toner and aftershave, others it's alum and toner, etc etc

Oh, I see. I've been doing this for over 15 years. My routine is pretty set. I don't change much. Adding a bit of this to my normal witch hazel mix is the biggest change I've made in a long time.

Thayers got rid of Thayers Lemon…..Thayers is dead to me

I'm mad they got rid of the Medicated.