
What an awesome shave Akhi! I have no experience with Old Spice but the way you describe this is inspiring me to give this soap a try!Thursday morning:
Warm shower
Yaqi 30mm Barber Pole
Super Speed/7 AM day 12
B&M Spice SS
Lubriderm Moisturizer
Stirling Spice EdT
This morning I was in the mood for a Shulton Old Spice shave and because I still can’t find my mug with a puck in it as well as my two back up pucks I went for the perfect substitute which is the B&M Spice. Man alive, this soap smells absolutely EXACTLY like the Shulton Old Spice - do I ever love that scent, the lather is such a delight, and it gives great post-shave care which the Lubriderm moisturizer really enhances. Finally the Stirling Spice fragrance which is another perfect copy of the Shulton Old Spice but with more longevity and that’s it that’s all. Three passes gave me such an awesome BBS shave and I enjoyed it so much!
Have a nice day - be well and stay safe!
JeffView attachment 158584

Thanks Akhi!What an awesome shave Akhi! I have no experience with Old Spice but the way you describe this is inspiring me to give this soap a try!

Beautiful shave Akhi!Thursday April 30, 2026
Brush: Dogwood Handcrafts
Bowl: Captain's Choice Copper
Soap: B&M Samhain
Razor: Henson AL13 + /Ti22 Handle
Henson: 10/14/2021 = 1684
Blade: KCG (1)
P/S: Bleu de Chanel
B&M's collaboration with Southern Witchcrafts is off the charts good! an amazing scent and the soap base is incredible.
View attachment 158598
Thanks Akhi!
The truth is that this soap is a treasure. I plan to keep it in my rotation for as long as possible. I also plan to buy the Stirling Spice soap because it apparently has the exact same scent as the B&M Spice and the Stirling Spice eau de toilette is 100% identical to the Shulton Old Spice fragrance. It’s MAGNIFICENT!
Jeff
Welcome remfan170, and thank you for your excellent post.April 30, 2026
• Bowl: Doug Smith Pottery – Ceramic Shave Bowl
• Brush: Semogue – 1470 (Boar)
• Razor: GEM – Junior 1912 Brass with Art Deco/Chain Link Handle
• Blade: Accuforge – GEM Microcoat
• Soap: Ariana & Evans – Peach & Cognac
• Aftershave: Stirling – Peach Aftershave Splash
• Balm: Stirling – Unscented Post Shave Balm
• Fragrance: House of Mammoth – Smash EDP
I’m coming right out and saying it: I don’t care for the artwork on this shave soap. Ariana & Evans does some really cool and thoughtful labels, but this one gives me the creeps. It makes me think of Medusa. Sad that with them having so many scents available, my favorite happens to be the one with the artwork I do not care for. The scent is spectacular, though. Peter has offered to make a fragrance for me of it for $70 (I believe he will do this for most scents). He even asked if I would like him to tone down the peach in it, but I am not sure I would want him to do that. Once I finish this sample of Smash, I will treat myself. Hopefully, that will coincide with the end of summer as I think Smash is a good summer scent and Peach & Cognac seems a bit more geared toward colder weather.
Smash has been discontinued (though I think there are some on sale at the HoM website) and was created by Will at Barrister and Mann. It is based on the cocktail: the bourbon smash. It features notes of peach, cane sugar, tobacco, bourbon, and hedione. I love the peach upfront, but there is something slightly cloying on the dry-down. Maybe it is the cane sugar or the hedione? There are some moments later in the day when it can be slightly obtrusive. But, still a lovely scent and perfect for a day with lovely weather.
The Shaving Cadre has a few gentlemen that are going to do Mystic May (using Mystic Water throughout the month of May). I encourage you to join or to check out Mystic Water if you have not. I will participate, but with one caveat since I have been sent so many samples and purchased some new stuff, Mystic May Every Other Day.
Have an awesome day, friends!
View attachment 158582
That’s great news my dear friend - this I didn’t know. I just placed a Stirling order today.Hey Jeff
I recently learned that going forward B&M products will be manufactured by the folks at Stirling. From what I understand they will continue to remain two separate and distinct product lines. That said, I will definitely purchase the soap you have whilst it is still in stock.

Beautiful shave Lantsman!Thursday, April 30, 2026
For the last day of April, it was on the chiller side. I decided Stirling 's Gin & Tonic would make for a very nice shave and i was right. I love the smell of the juniper berries in it along with the lime. Great shave with the Merica and a 5th use Personna Gem Diamond Glide DE.
View attachment 158613
Overall Rating: ★★★★★ (Epic Shave!)
Smoothness: ★★★★★ (BBS Perfection)
Irritation: ★★☆☆☆ (Barely There)
Time of Day: Afternoon
Blade Uses: 5
Passes: 2
Razor: Yates Precision Materials Merica SS Stonewashed
Blade: Personna Gem Platinum Diamond Glide
Soap: Stirling Soap Co Gin & Tonic
Shaving Bowl: HC&C Stainless Steel Straight Walled Bowl
Brush: PAA Atomic Rocket
Pre-Shave: Hot Shower
Pre-Shave 2: Van Der Hagen Hypo-Allergenic Fragrance Free Glycerin Puck
Aftershave: PAA Alum Solid Block No slip Grip.
Aftershave 2: Thayer's Cucumber Facial Toner - Witch Hazel
Aftershave 3: Stirling Soap Co Unscented Aftershave
Aftershave 4: Stirling Soap Co Unscented - Post-Shave Balm
Generated by Shaving Sherpa — Shaving Sherpa - Master Your Wet Shaving Journey