elmerPHuD
Shave Member
For me it would be Chiseled Face's Midnight Stag, PAA's Sangre DeDrago, & Declaration Darkfall. All 3 in soap and post-shaves. I would also throw in one EDT - Varvatos Dark Rebel. They are not crowd pleasers by any stretch, but I ♥ them! I have CBL's Horsepower on order, so that one may join that pantheon as it has some similar scent nots to Midnight Stag.