The Shaving Cadre

Welcome to The Shaving Cadre, a forum dedicated to gentlemanly discourse about wet shaving and other topics of common interests. Membership is always free so register today and join in the fun

LEA Classic Shaving Soap in wooden bowl

dkeester

"TSC's Master of Bourbon"
A few pictures:
IMG_20200203_093459282.jpgIMG_20200203_093730735.jpgIMG_20200203_093713286.jpgIMG_20200203_093546664.jpgIMG_20200203_093605816.jpg


The review:
Like many wet shavers, I am a fan of hard soaps. However, so far in my wet shaving career I have found only a few that are worthwhile but there are many that I haven't tried yet. The rest suck. (I am looking at you TOBS puck.) My hard soap list is short: Tabac, MWF, & CBL Tonsorial. Well, that list is getting a new addition.

LEA Classic is a hard, milled puck that when unwrapped is devoid of any markings. It is just a white puck of soap that is so bone dry as to be porous. This reminded me of how a puck of MWF feels when first unwrapped, except the LEA Classic might be even drier than MWF. I knew right away that this puck would require blooming. Before placing it back into the bowl, I held it to my nose. The sandalwood and moss scent with a hint of menthol is vey pleasant and far from overpowering. After placing the puck back in the bowl I opened the bottle of LEA Classic AS splash. The AS matches the soap and is also quite pleasant. Before covering the soap up I put some water on top of it then immediately dumped it off. I then covered the soap with the lid to the bowl.

The next morning (today) the soap was moist and a little softer. I put a few drops more water on top of it and hopped into the shower. After my shower I took a synthetic brush, wet the bristles, and then squeezed much of the water out. I then loaded directly from the puck. The soap is more foamy than many when it loads, but I had no problem getting plenty of soap into my brush and into my lather bowl. I then added a teaspoon or two of water and proceeded to build what appeared to be a very nice lather. Shaving with it showed it to be protective and comfortable, but lacking slickness. (If this happens with a harder soap it means that the lather is too dry.) I added a couple of teaspoons more water for the second pass and was rewarded with a slick, comfortable, and protective lather that gave me a really, really comfortable BBS. Finishing the shave with the matching AS left me feeling great and smelling good. The scent has faded in the few hours since finishing the shave, but it was never that strong to begin with.

I have only used this for one shave so far, but, since it is my current 3017 project, it is going to get much, much more use. So far I would say it has similar performance to Tabac or CBL Tonsorial with similar water needs. Give this soap more than you think it needs and you will probably be close to the right amount. CBL Tonsorial has a leg up on this soap in one area, just as it does on Tabac. LEA Classic is available in one scent only. CBL has a range of options. So, if you aren't a fan of sandalwood and moss, you probably aren't going to find this soap as enjoyable as I do.

LEA Classic is going on to my list of soaps to restock when it is gone. Considering that this soap has been around for a long time now, I am surprised that there aren't more people talking about it. I only found one review from 2015 on a different forum. Hopefully some of you other Cadre members will give this one a try. At around $12 US for a 100 gram refill puck and around $24 for the puck with the wooden bowl, I feel that this is soap is definitely a good value.

I am really excited to use it again tomorrow.
 
A few pictures:
View attachment 16422View attachment 16423View attachment 16424View attachment 16425View attachment 16426


The review:
Like many wet shavers, I am a fan of hard soaps. However, so far in my wet shaving career I have found only a few that are worthwhile but there are many that I haven't tried yet. The rest suck. (I am looking at you TOBS puck.) My hard soap list is short: Tabac, MWF, & CBL Tonsorial. Well, that list is getting a new addition.

LEA Classic is a hard, milled puck that when unwrapped is devoid of any markings. It is just a white puck of soap that is so bone dry as to be porous. This reminded me of how a puck of MWF feels when first unwrapped, except the LEA Classic might be even drier than MWF. I knew right away that this puck would require blooming. Before placing it back into the bowl, I held it to my nose. The sandalwood and moss scent with a hint of menthol is vey pleasant and far from overpowering. After placing the puck back in the bowl I opened the bottle of LEA Classic AS splash. The AS matches the soap and is also quite pleasant. Before covering the soap up I put some water on top of it then immediately dumped it off. I then covered the soap with the lid to the bowl.

The next morning (today) the soap was moist and a little softer. I put a few drops more water on top of it and hopped into the shower. After my shower I took a synthetic brush, wet the bristles, and then squeezed much of the water out. I then loaded directly from the puck. The soap is more foamy than many when it loads, but I had no problem getting plenty of soap into my brush and into my lather bowl. I then added a teaspoon or two of water and proceeded to build what appeared to be a very nice lather. Shaving with it showed it to be protective and comfortable, but lacking slickness. (If this happens with a harder soap it means that the lather is too dry.) I added a couple of teaspoons more water for the second pass and was rewarded with a slick, comfortable, and protective lather that gave me a really, really comfortable BBS. Finishing the shave with the matching AS left me feeling great and smelling good. The scent has faded in the few hours since finishing the shave, but it was never that strong to begin with.

I have only used this for one shave so far, but, since it is my current 3017 project, it is going to get much, much more use. So far I would say it has similar performance to Tabac or CBL Tonsorial with similar water needs. Give this soap more than you think it needs and you will probably be close to the right amount. CBL Tonsorial has a leg up on this soap in one area, just as it does on Tabac. LEA Classic is available in one scent only. CBL has a range of options. So, if you aren't a fan of sandalwood and moss, you probably aren't going to find this soap as enjoyable as I do.

LEA Classic is going on to my list of soaps to restock when it is gone. Considering that this soap has been around for a long time now, I am surprised that there aren't more people talking about it. I only found one review from 2015 on a different forum. Hopefully some of you other Cadre members will give this one a try. At around $12 US for a 100 gram refill puck and around $24 for the puck with the wooden bowl, I feel that this is soap is definitely a good value.

I am really excited to use it again tomorrow.

On my Radar now. Thanks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
They have changed their formulas more times than I can relate in the past few years. The shave stick was originally great, then not so great, great again and now not so great. o_O
 
Yeah, remember the stick going back an forth. As a result, not a brand I paid much attention to. So many artisans, so much better.....
 
Hmmm I am tempted. but the 'moss' note makes me nervous.

THe price seems spot on for the soap and bowl, but honestly seems a tad steep for the AS. I might buy the bowl and add the AS later if I like the scent! DARN YOU!
You're welcome! :D
 
Hmmm I am tempted. but the 'moss' note makes me nervous.

THe price seems spot on for the soap and bowl, but honestly seems a tad steep for the AS. I might buy the bowl and add the AS later if I like the scent! DARN YOU!
Not to make it worse, but i'd also be nervous about the Sandalwood.

If you take Mystic Waters sandalwood and coconut, I pick up a strong dark woody scent (plus coconut).

On the other side of the coin, Fine Santal absolute has Sandalwood smelling like a mix between a lite almost non-perceptible wood and a strong hay smell (to me).

Two completely different smells for what's supposed to be the same wood.
 
Not to make it worse, but i'd also be nervous about the Sandalwood.

If you take Mystic Waters sandalwood and coconut, I pick up a strong dark woody scent (plus coconut).

On the other side of the coin, Fine Santal absolute has Sandalwood smelling like a mix between a lite almost non-perceptible wood and a strong hay smell (to me).

Two completely different smells for what's supposed to be the same wood.


Oh I agree. Sandalwood can be all over the place. I usually like them all, although not equally. But moss, oakmoss, and hippie (patchouli) I am VERY picky about. They need to be done right.
 
Not to make it worse, but i'd also be nervous about the Sandalwood.

If you take Mystic Waters sandalwood and coconut, I pick up a strong dark woody scent (plus coconut).

On the other side of the coin, Fine Santal absolute has Sandalwood smelling like a mix between a lite almost non-perceptible wood and a strong hay smell (to me).

Two completely different smells for what's supposed to be the same wood.
There are a number of different sandalwood oils that come from different areas of the world. So, it is not one scent. It is a family of scents. I find these scents to be some of the most inoffensive scents on the planet. I see no reason to be nervous even though sandalwood varies so much.
 
There are a number of different sandalwood oils that come from different areas of the world. So, it is not one scent. It is a family of scents. I find these scents to be some of the most inoffensive scents on the planet. I see no reason to be nervous even though sandalwood varies so much.

It's odd, but for me, that Santal Absolute hay-like smell is nauseating. Something about it didn't sit well with me.

Still, Lea did intrigue me as I was considering trying a shave stick again. The addition of oakmoss and menthol is going to make it a different animal (presuming it's the same Sandalwood to begin with).
 
It's odd, but for me, that Santal Absolute hay-like smell is nauseating. Something about it didn't sit well with me.

Still, Lea did intrigue me as I was considering trying a shave stick again. The addition of oakmoss and menthol is going to make it a different animal (presuming it's the same Sandalwood to begin with).
The sandalwood in the LEA Classic is different than the Santal Absolut to my nose.

Also, FYI, the LEA Classic is not available in a shave stick. The LEA stick is a different formula and probably different scent.
 
The sandalwood in the LEA Classic is different than the Santal Absolut to my nose.

Also, FYI, the LEA Classic is not available in a shave stick. The LEA stick is a different formula and probably different scent.
Ohhh. I just assumed they were the same. Glad I decided to pop into this topic, lol. I would have made an error... Well potentially, who know if the stick is also a nice smell. [emoji846]

Thanks @dkeester
 
Okay so a purchase was made. (FYI cheaper on eBay by a little bit and free shipping) I am going to hold off on the aftershave since I have been told the scent is the same. I had to get away from Maggards as quickly as possible because the shopping cart was getting very full and big!

@mrdoug the stick to me is just a nice clean soap smell. Very neutral. But a great performer. Not sure your experience with shave sticks... but the best stick for me in performance and scent is by FAR La Toja.
 
Okay so a purchase was made. (FYI cheaper on eBay by a little bit and free shipping) I am going to hold off on the aftershave since I have been told the scent is the same. I had to get away from Maggards as quickly as possible because the shopping cart was getting very full and big!

@mrdoug the stick to me is just a nice clean soap smell. Very neutral. But a great performer. Not sure your experience with shave sticks... but the best stick for me in performance and scent is by FAR La Toja.

Thanks @Cvargo for the recommendation. I decided to try the La Toja first. [emoji106]
 
Wow, the LEA Classic is great soap. I have used it for over 20 shaves in a row so far and am quite pleased with the performance. This is a great old-school, triple milled puck of soap. I highly recommend it.
 
I used the stick on Monday on 3 day growth of beard and was rewarded with an outstanding shave. Why don’t we use sticks more again?
 
Back
Top